Should you hang Cleet?

Should You Hang Cleet?

Red Dead Redemption 2, Rockstar Games’ open-world western epic, presents us with a multitude of decisions that shape the fate of its protagonist, Arthur Morgan. One of the earliest and most crucial choices facing Arthur is whether to spare or hang Cleet, a low-ranking member of the Van der Linde gang. This decision might seem trivial at first glance, but its consequences impact the story and the way Arthur is perceived by others.

Cleet: The Man in Question

Cleet is an awkward and insignificant member of the gang, who becomes caught up in Micah Bell’s plan to take advantage of the Van der Linde gang’s vulnerable position. Micah’s loyalty to the gang is faltering, and Cleet’s fate becomes intertwined with Micah’s motivations.

Should You Spare Him?

When confronted by Arthur, Cleet claims to have been manipulated by Micah and tries to convince Arthur to spare him. Cleet’s fear and desperation are palpable, and Arthur’s empathy for the man might stir a sense of moral urgency. However, the easy way out would be to hang Cleet, cutting off any potential harm or betrayal he might cause. [Should you kill Cleet?]

Table: Consequences of Hang Cleet vs. Spar Cleet

On one hand, if you choose to hang Cleet, you will achieve a higher honor rating with the Van der Linde gang. This decision shows you are committed to protecting your comrades and taking swift action against potential threats. It also allows Micah’s betrayal to be revealed earlier in the story, reducing the chances of his covert actions affecting the gang further.

On the other hand, if you decide to spare Cleet, you will maintain a slightly lower honor rating with the gang. However, it is crucial to note that Cleet’s actions were largely driven by Micah’s manipulation. Letting Cleet live presents a chance for Micah’s influence to affect his actions, potentially creating alternative story paths. For example, Cleet’s survival could lead to conflicting loyalties, internal conflicts, or even unintended alliances within the gang.

Key Takeaways:

• Hang Cleet for a higher honor rating and a faster reveal of Micah’s betrayal, but risk creating internal tensions within the gang.
• Spare Cleet to create alternative story paths, showcasing the complexity of the character’s relationships and loyalties.

What Can We Learn from Cleet’s Fate?

In Red Dead Redemption 2, Cleet’s decisions serve as a microcosm for the consequences of our actions. By weighing the pros and cons of both options, we gain valuable insight into the characters we interact with and the potential outcomes of our choices.

Ultimately, whether to spare or hang Cleet represents a critical turning point in the story. Your decision will have a lasting impact on the game’s narrative and the fate of the characters. So, the question remains: Should You Hang Cleet? The choice is yours