Should I Go for the Money or Help John?
Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic open-world western game that offers players a wide range of choices and outcomes. One of the most critical decisions players face is whether to help John Marston or go back for the money. In this article, we’ll explore the implications of each choice and help you decide which one is best for you.
The Honorable Ending: Helping John
Choosing to help John Marston will trigger the Honorable ending, which is widely considered the best ending for the game. By doing so, you’ll help John defeat Micah and save his life. This choice also has a profound impact on the game’s narrative, as it leads to a more positive conclusion and a sense of closure.
The Unhonorable Ending: Going Back for the Money
On the other hand, if you choose to go back for the money, you’ll trigger the Unhonorable ending. This choice is often seen as a way to prioritize personal gain over doing the right thing. By doing so, you’ll abandon John to his fate and potentially seal his demise.
Consequences of Each Choice
Here’s a breakdown of the consequences of each choice:
| Choice | Consequences |
|---|---|
| Help John | Honorable ending, positive narrative conclusion, John’s life is saved |
| Go Back for the Money | Unhonorable ending, John’s life is likely lost, negative narrative impact |
Why the Honorable Ending is Better
There are several reasons why the Honorable ending is considered the better choice. For one, it leads to a more positive conclusion to the game’s story. Additionally, helping John Marston is a more altruistic and honorable choice that aligns with the game’s themes of loyalty and redemption.
What About the Money?
You may be wondering what’s so important about going back for the money. While it may seem like a tempting option, it’s worth considering the potential consequences. Going back for the money could lead to John’s death, which would be a tragic and potentially game-changing event.
John’s Debt and the Future
Another important aspect to consider is John’s debt and the future of his family. By helping John, you’ll be supporting him in his efforts to clear his debt and secure a better future for his family. Going back for the money, on the other hand, could potentially worsen John’s financial situation and put his family’s well-being at risk.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the decision to help John Marston or go back for the money is up to you. However, considering the consequences of each choice, it’s clear that the Honorable ending is the better option. By helping John, you’ll be making a choice that aligns with the game’s themes and has a positive impact on the narrative.