Does Hexproof Stop Counterspell?
In the world of Magic: The Gathering, Hexproof and Counterspell are two powerful abilities that can greatly impact the gameplay. But do they really stop each other? Let’s dive into the intricacies of these abilities to find out.
A Direct Answer
No, Hexproof does not stop Counterspell. Counterspell is an ability that can counter target spell, while Hexproof is an ability that prevents a permanent or player from being the target of spells or abilities. These two abilities operate under different rules and are not mutually exclusive.
Underlying Rules
To better understand the relationship between Hexproof and Counterspell, let’s take a closer look at the underlying rules.
Hexproof
- Hexproof is an evergreen keyword ability that prevents a permanent or player from being the target of spells or abilities.
- It doesn’t prevent spells or abilities from targeting the permanent or player, but rather prevents spells or abilities from targeting it specifically.
- Hexproof only applies to spells and abilities that target the permanent or player, not spells or abilities that affect all permanents or players in play.
Counterspell
- Counterspell is an ability that can counter target spell.
- It allows the caster to counter a spell and send it back to the caster’s hand.
- Counterspell can be used to counter any spell, including those with Hexproof.
Interplay between Hexproof and Counterspell
Given the underlying rules of Hexproof and Counterspell, we can see that Counterspell can still target a Hexproof permanent or player.
- Counterspell can target a Hexproof permanent, allowing the caster to counter the spell and send it back to the caster’s hand.
- Counterspell can also target a Hexproof player, allowing the caster to counter a spell and send it back to the caster’s hand.
Workarounds
However, there are some workarounds to consider. For example, if an opponent has a Hexproof permanent, they can use a spell that doesn’t target the permanent specifically, such as Destroy All or a sacrifice effect. This can bypass the Hexproof ability and allow the permanent to be destroyed.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Hexproof and Counterspell are two distinct abilities that operate under different rules. Hexproof is an ability that prevents a permanent or player from being the target of spells or abilities, while Counterspell is an ability that can counter target spell.
While Hexproof does not stop Counterspell, there are workarounds to consider. Understanding the underlying rules of these abilities can help you make informed decisions on the battlefield.
Further Reading
For more information on Hexproof, Counterspell, and other Magic: The Gathering abilities, check out the official Magic: The Gathering website or consult the Comprehensive Rules.
Glossary
- Hexproof: An evergreen keyword ability that prevents a permanent or player from being the target of spells or abilities.
- Counterspell: An ability that can counter target spell.
- Permanents: Cards in play that are not instants or sorceries.