Should I Give the Girl the Red Jeweled Brooch?
The Red Jeweled Brooch is a coveted item in the world of Bloodborne, and it’s a crucial decision that players must make. Should you give it to the young Yharnam girl, or should you withhold it? In this article, we’ll delve into the pros and cons of each option, so you can make an informed decision.
What’s at Stake?
When you obtain the Red Jeweled Brooch, you’ll be faced with a choice: give it to the young Yharnam girl or keep it for yourself. The decision you make will have a significant impact on the story and the world of Bloodborne.
Option 1: Give the Brooch to the Girl
Giving the brooch to the girl will result in her becoming a messenger, wearing the brooch and becoming a symbol of your gift. This option is considered the "good" choice, as it leads to a more positive outcome for the girl and potentially for the world of Yharnam.
Pros of Giving the Brooch to the Girl:
- Positive Outcome: Giving the brooch to the girl will lead to a more positive outcome for her and potentially for the world of Yharnam.
- Better Reward: Giving the brooch to the girl will result in a better reward, as she will become a messenger and wear the brooch as a symbol of your gift.
- Increased Story Impact: Giving the brooch to the girl will have a significant impact on the story, as it will lead to a more positive outcome and potentially change the fate of Yharnam.
Cons of Giving the Brooch to the Girl:
- No Immediate Reward: Giving the brooch to the girl will not result in an immediate reward, as you will not receive anything in return.
- Risk of Negative Consequences: Giving the brooch to the girl may have negative consequences, as it may lead to a worse outcome for the world of Yharnam.
Option 2: Withhold the Brooch
Withholding the brooch will result in the girl becoming a messenger without the brooch, and she will not wear it as a symbol of your gift. This option is considered the "bad" choice, as it leads to a more negative outcome for the girl and potentially for the world of Yharnam.
Pros of Withholding the Brooch:
- Immediate Reward: Withholding the brooch will result in an immediate reward, as you will receive the brooch and its powers.
- No Negative Consequences: Withholding the brooch will not have negative consequences, as it will not lead to a worse outcome for the world of Yharnam.
Cons of Withholding the Brooch:
- Negative Outcome: Withholding the brooch will lead to a negative outcome for the girl and potentially for the world of Yharnam.
- Worse Reward: Withholding the brooch will result in a worse reward, as the girl will not become a messenger and wear the brooch as a symbol of your gift.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the decision to give the Red Jeweled Brooch to the girl or withhold it is a crucial one. Giving the brooch to the girl will lead to a more positive outcome and potentially change the fate of Yharnam, but it will not result in an immediate reward. Withholding the brooch will result in an immediate reward, but it will lead to a negative outcome and potentially worsen the fate of Yharnam.
Ultimately, the decision is up to you, the player. Weigh the pros and cons of each option carefully and make an informed decision that aligns with your playstyle and preferences.
Table: Red Jeweled Brooch Decision Matrix
| Option | Positive Outcome | Better Reward | Increased Story Impact | Immediate Reward | No Negative Consequences |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Give the Brooch | |||||
| Withhold the Brooch |
Note: indicates a positive outcome or benefit, while indicates a negative outcome or drawback.
Additional Tips
- Save Before Making a Decision: Before making a decision, save your game to ensure that you can experiment with different choices and outcomes.
- Consider the Story: Think about the story and the world of Yharnam, and how your decision will impact it.
- Weigh the Pros and Cons: Carefully weigh the pros and cons of each option to make an informed decision.
- Experiment and Replay: Don’t be afraid to experiment and replay the game to see the different outcomes and consequences of your decision.