Why is Talion not canon?

Why is Talion not Canon?

Talion, the protagonist of Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor and Middle-earth: Shadow of War, is a complex and intriguing character. However, despite his fascinating backstory and abilities, Talion is not considered part of the official canon of J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth. In this article, we will explore the reasons why Talion is not canon and delve into the implications of this decision.

Direct Answer

Talion is not canon because he does not originate from the works of J.R.R. Tolkien. The games were developed by Monolith Productions and published by Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment, and while they are set in the world of Middle-earth, they are not considered part of the official canon.

Background

Talion’s story begins with his life as a Ranger of the Black Gate, where he is tasked with protecting the Black Gate of Mordor from the forces of darkness. However, his life takes a dramatic turn when he is captured and forced to watch as the Black Hand of Sauron slays his wife and son. Talion is then brought before Sauron, who tortures him and forces him to watch as his family is killed. This trauma has a profound effect on Talion, and he becomes consumed by a desire for revenge against Sauron and his minions.

The Problem with Talion’s Story

While Talion’s story is compelling, it is not consistent with the events described in Tolkien’s books. In the book, Sauron’s power is not as great as it is in the games, and the Black Hand of Sauron is not a prominent figure. Additionally, the events of the games do not align with the timeline of the book, and the characters and locations are not consistent with the descriptions in the book.

Implications

The decision to make Talion not canon has significant implications for the world of Middle-earth. It means that the events of the games are not considered part of the official history of Middle-earth, and the characters and locations in the games are not considered part of the official canon. This can make it difficult for fans to reconcile the events of the games with the events of the book, and can create confusion about the nature of the world of Middle-earth.

Comparison with Other Games

Other games set in the world of Middle-earth, such as The Lord of the Rings Online and The Hobbit, are considered part of the official canon. These games are developed in collaboration with the Tolkien Estate and are designed to be consistent with the events and characters described in the book. In contrast, the Shadow of Mordor and Shadow of War games are developed independently and are not considered part of the official canon.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Talion is not canon because he does not originate from the works of J.R.R. Tolkien. While his story is compelling, it is not consistent with the events described in the book, and the characters and locations in the games are not considered part of the official canon. The decision to make Talion not canon has significant implications for the world of Middle-earth, and fans of the book may find it difficult to reconcile the events of the games with the events of the book.

Additional Information

• Talion’s Backstory: Talion’s backstory is not consistent with the events described in the book. In the book, Sauron’s power is not as great as it is in the games, and the Black Hand of Sauron is not a prominent figure.
• The Black Hand of Sauron: The Black Hand of Sauron is not a prominent figure in the book, and its role in the games is not consistent with the events described in the book.
• Timeline: The events of the games do not align with the timeline of the book, and the characters and locations in the games are not consistent with the descriptions in the book.
• Canon: The decision to make Talion not canon has significant implications for the world of Middle-earth. It means that the events of the games are not considered part of the official history of Middle-earth, and the characters and locations in the games are not considered part of the official canon.

Table: Comparison of Talion’s Story with the Book

Bullets List: Implications of Talion not being Canon

• The events of the games are not considered part of the official history of Middle-earth
• The characters and locations in the games are not considered part of the official canon
• Fans of the book may find it difficult to reconcile the events of the games with the events of the book
• The decision may create confusion about the nature of the world of Middle-earth

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YRNRdomhqG8