Can a Good Character Join the Dark Brotherhood?
Introduction
In the world of Elder Scrolls, morality is not a strict guideline, but rather a blurred line. Players have the freedom to make their characters as black-hearted as they want. One question that often plagues moral adventurers is, can a good character join the Dark Brotherhood? Can one forsake their commitment to honor, justice, and ethics and join an organization renowned for its villainous pursuits?
Short Answer: No
Spoiler alert, not much redemption to be had for those tempted by the darkness. From a moral perspective, no, it’s not feasible for a genuinely good character to join the Dark Brotherhood. Why not? Well, here’s a breakdown:
Long Answer: Let’s Look into the Fine Print
For a good character, it’s best to prioritize a different faction. A strong moral compass guides many individuals, setting a firm commitment to moral integrity and making it tough for these protagonists to toe the Brotherhood’s, cough deadly line. You’ll quickly discover that any decent chap with a **" Good Character" status is naturally more inclined toward more savory options.
Why are those inclined toward malevolence naturally drawn to the Brotherhood?
• Their inherent flaws (demonstrate questionable moral beliefs, lacking the capacity to uphold conventional principles) create circumstances making it suitable for individuals inclined toward vice
• Strong moral sense repelled; the light within (symbolizing internal justice)
• Contrary dispositions render those capable, yet incapable, from upholding high standards **Morality-First vs Morality-of-Cultrure debate: Should our actions comply with, while also staying loyal and authentic to values & goals?
Supporting Data (from NPCs): Garelle Herin is particularly vocal. This outspoken warrior, convinced she won the war by engaging in ’till-dead-’em actions’, firmly opposed our joining The Order: Garelle expressed disappointment as we had an obvious weakness for an open relationship – dramatically – It doesn’t belong in it because then what’s in "THE DARK. There seems to believe "morals" was always her favorite word because this line indicates that his primary objection concerns the influence their involvement.
Another to be highlighted: Ulfgar Hlams ‘nominative in the most beautiful word and the fact of death by the other world with your own ‘The words Ulfgar ‘You think you find them out the rest you take’, not by Ulfgar that would otherwise exist
For anyone aiming to balance between righteousness and the potential Dark Arts experience, their alignment or background should support that objective or else such efforts (would be thwarted to).