Can a player with protection be attacked?

Can a Player with Protection be Attacked?

Protection is a crucial aspect of Magic: The Gathering, providing players with a shield against harm. But, can a player with protection still be attacked? In this article, we’ll delve into the world of protection and explore the answer to this question.

Direct Answer: Yes, a player with protection can still be attacked

While protection provides a layer of immunity, it’s not a foolproof shield. In fact, there are several ways a player with protection can still be attacked. Let’s break it down:

• Global destroy effects: These effects, such as those from the Phyrexian Arena, can destroy creatures and other permanents, including those with protection. This means that even if a player has protection, they can still be targeted by these effects.
• Combat damage: Combat damage, such as from Commander damage, can still be dealt to a player with protection. While the damage may not reduce the player’s life total, it can still have an impact on the game state.
• Other forms of damage: Other forms of damage, such as Poison or Lifegain, can still affect a player with protection.

Protection Variants

There are several variants of protection, each with its own rules and interactions. Let’s take a closer look:

• Protection from everything: This variant provides protection from all sources, including creatures, spells, and abilities. However, it’s important to note that this protection doesn’t extend to global destroy effects.
• Protection from a player: This variant provides protection from the targeted player, preventing them from targeting the protected player with spells, abilities, or attacks.
• Godly protection: This variant, also known as New player protection, provides protection for new players from higher-level players, preventing them from being attacked or pillaged.

Consequences of Protection

While protection can provide a layer of security, it’s not without consequences. Here are a few things to consider:

• Limited interaction: Protection can limit a player’s ability to interact with other players, making it difficult to play around protection-based strategies.
• Unpredictability: Protection can make it difficult to predict how a game will play out, as the protection can change the dynamics of the game.
• Opportunities for exploitation: Protection can create opportunities for exploitation, such as targeting a player with protection using a global destroy effect.

Conclusion

In conclusion, a player with protection can still be attacked, but it’s important to understand the different variants of protection and their interactions. While protection can provide a layer of security, it’s not a foolproof shield, and there are still ways to target a player with protection. By understanding the consequences of protection, players can better navigate the world of Magic: The Gathering and make informed decisions about when to use protection and when to take risks.

Key Takeaways

• Protection is not a foolproof shield and can still be attacked.
• Global destroy effects can destroy creatures and permanents with protection.
• Combat damage can still be dealt to a player with protection.
• Protection from everything does not extend to global destroy effects.
• Protection from a player prevents the targeted player from targeting the protected player.
• Godly protection provides protection for new players from higher-level players.

Table: Protection Variants

Bullets: Consequences of Protection

• Limited interaction
• Unpredictability
• Opportunities for exploitation