Can Arthur Live in Red Dead?
The answer to this question is a resounding no. In the game Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan’s fate is sealed from the very beginning. Tuberculosis (TB) has taken hold of his lungs, and it’s a disease that will ultimately consume him. There is no known cure for TB in the game’s world, and Arthur’s condition deteriorates over time.
Arthur’s Fatal Condition
Arthur’s TB is not just a minor annoyance, but a life-threatening condition that affects his health and overall well-being. As the disease progresses, Arthur’s energy levels decline, and he becomes more susceptible to other illnesses and infections. His ability to fight and defend himself is also impaired, making him a less effective outlaw in the end.
Why Can’t Arthur Live?
Several reasons contribute to Arthur’s untimely demise. First and foremost, there is no known cure for TB in the game’s world. Medical treatment at the time was limited, and antibiotics did not yet exist. Second, the game’s story is centered around the Van der Linde gang’s decline, and Arthur’s death serves as a pivotal moment in the narrative. Finally, Rockstar Games, the game’s developer, wanted to create a sense of mortality and consequence in the game. Arthur’s death is a reminder that the characters in the game are not invincible and that their actions have real-world consequences.
A Life of Sacrifice
In the game, Arthur makes a selfless decision to help John Marston escape, knowing that his own life is near its end. This selfless act demonstrates Arthur’s commitment to his gang and his loyalty to his fellow outlaws. Despite being gravely ill, Arthur continues to fight and support his gang until the very end, ultimately sacrificing himself to ensure John’s safety.
Can John Survive?
In contrast, John Marston is not afflicted with TB. However, he is badly injured and struggling to come to terms with his own mortality. Despite his injuries, John is able to survive the events of the game, and his story continues into Red Dead Redemption.
Why Can’t John Swim?
In Red Dead Redemption 2, John Marston is unable to swim. This is likely a nod to the original Red Dead Redemption game, where John was also a poor swimmer. In both games, John’s swimming abilities are incredibly poor, and he is often seen struggling to stay afloat. This quirk adds a touch of humor to the game and serves as a reminder of John’s flaws as a character.
A Comparison with John
When comparing Arthur and John, it’s clear that they are two fundamentally different characters. Arthur is a natural leader, skilled in combat, and deeply committed to his gang. John, on the other hand, is a former outlaw struggling to find redemption and settle down. While both characters share a similar fate (Arthur’s death and John’s injuries), their motivations and actions are distinct and shaped by their unique experiences.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Arthur Morgan cannot live in Red Dead Redemption 2. His condition is terminal, and his death serves as a pivotal moment in the game’s narrative. While his selfless act of sacrificing himself for John Marston’s safety is a powerful reminder of his loyalty and commitment to his gang. The game’s story and characters are shaped by the decisions made by Rockstar Games, and Arthur’s demise is a key part of that narrative.