Can Wish Cards Pull from Exile?
In the world of Magic: The Gathering, cards can be exiled from the game, removing them from the player’s deck, graveyard, or battlefield. This can happen through various effects, such as cards that exile, abilities that send cards to exile, or even the "exile" zone itself. But what happens when a card is exiled? Can it still be played or manipulated by Wish cards?
The Answer: No, Wish Cards Cannot Pull from Exile
The short answer is no, Wish cards cannot pull cards from exile. Exiled cards are considered "out of the game" and are not accessible to any card effects, including Wish cards. This is because the exile zone is a separate zone from the game’s other zones, such as the deck, graveyard, and battlefield.
Why Can’t Wish Cards Pull from Exile?
There are several reasons why Wish cards cannot pull from exile:
- Exiled cards are not considered "in the game": Exiled cards are not part of the game’s current state, and therefore cannot be targeted or affected by card effects.
- Exile is a permanent removal: When a card is exiled, it is permanently removed from the game, and cannot be recovered or manipulated in any way.
- Wish cards can only target "in the game" cards: Wish cards can only target cards that are currently in the game, such as cards on the battlefield, in the graveyard, or in the player’s hand. Exiled cards are not "in the game" and therefore cannot be targeted by Wish cards.
Examples of Cards That Cannot be Pulled from Exile
Here are some examples of cards that cannot be pulled from exile:
- Mangara of Corondor: This card can only return cards from the graveyard, not from exile.
- Unmake: This card can only return cards from the graveyard or the battlefield, not from exile.
- Pull from Eternity: This card can only return cards from the graveyard, not from exile.
Consequences of Exiling Cards
Exiling cards can have significant consequences for a player’s game state. For example:
- Card disadvantage: Exiling a card can lead to card disadvantage, as the player loses access to a potentially powerful card.
- Loss of card advantage: Exiling a card can also lead to loss of card advantage, as the player is unable to use the card’s abilities or effects.
- Impact on gameplay: Exiling cards can significantly impact gameplay, as it can remove important cards from the game and disrupt a player’s strategy.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Wish cards cannot pull cards from exile. Exiled cards are considered "out of the game" and are not accessible to any card effects, including Wish cards. Players should be aware of the consequences of exiling cards and plan accordingly to minimize the impact on their gameplay.