Can you double block first strike?

Can You Double Block First Strike?

First strike is a keyword ability in Magic: The Gathering that allows a creature to deal combat damage before all other creatures attack. On the surface, it may seem like a simple mechanic, but it can get complex when you add another layer to it – blocking. Specifically, can you double block a creature with first strike?

Answer:

No, you cannot double block a creature with first strike. Let’s dive into why this is the case.

How Blocking Works

When a creature with first strike attacks, it deals damage to a blocker in the first combat damage step, before all other creatures have a chance to deal damage. If a creature blocks the attacker, it means that it will absorb the damage from the attack and potentially kill the blocker if it takes enough damage. However, when a creature with first strike is blocked, the first strike step is not the same as the regular damage step. The regular damage step still occurs after the first strike step, but the blocked creature’s damage is effectively "locked in" for the purpose of dealing damage to the blocker.

What Happens When You Block a Creature with First Strike

When you block a creature with first strike, it’s important to remember that the creature is only attacking once – during the first strike step. After the first strike step, the blocked creature’s damage is not applicable, and any remaining damage it had dealt is ignored. This means that even if you try to double block the creature, you will not successfully block it a second time.

Example:

Suppose you have a 2/2 black creature with first strike named "Shriekhallow Ghoul" and you want to block it with your 3/3 blue creature, "Azura’s Crusader". The first strike step occurs, and Shriekhallow Ghoul deals 2 damage to Azura’s Crusader. Azura’s Crusader takes the 2 damage, and now you’re left with a situation where Azura’s Crusader is still in the game but with only 1 toughness left. From this point on, you cannot block Shriekhallow Ghoul a second time, as it has already dealt its first strike damage and is not attacking again.

Can You Still Use Multiple Creatures to Block First Strike?

While you cannot double block a creature with first strike, you can still use multiple creatures to block it in a single attack step. For example, if you have two creatures with toughness 2 and 3, respectively, you can block a creature with first strike that’s attacking for 5 or more damage. In this case, the 2-toughness creature will die first, and the 3-toughness creature will die after taking the remaining damage. Just keep in mind that only the first creature that is assigned to block the first strike attack will receive damage from it.

Why Can’t You Double Block First Strike?

Magic: The Gathering’s game designers introduced the concept of first strike to add strategic depth to combat and give players more options for creature design. If you allowed double blocking for first strike creatures, it would render the mechanic somewhat redundant, as the second block would simply ignore the first block’s effect. By design, first strike is intended to give the attacking creature an advantage in combat, and blocking it with two creatures would undo that advantage.

Conclusion

In summary, no, you cannot double block a creature with first strike. When blocking a creature with first strike, the first strike step only occurs once, and the blocked creature’s damage is effectively "locked in" for the purpose of dealing damage to the blocker. You can still use multiple creatures to block a creature with first strike, but each creature can only take damage from it once. Understanding this mechanism is crucial for effective game play in Magic: The Gathering, so be sure to keep it in mind when constructing your decks or making combat decisions.

Here’s a summary table of the article’s main points: