Can you get Arthur’s horses as John?

Can You Get Arthur’s Horses as John?

As you progress through the story of Red Dead Redemption 2, you’ll likely develop a strong bond with Arthur Morgan’s horses. With the vast open plains and diverse terrains to explore, a good horse can make a significant difference in your gaming experience. But what happens to these horses when Arthur passes away? Can John Marston, the protagonist of the first Red Dead Redemption game, inherit these majestic steeds?

Unfortunately, the Answer is No

As the story of Red Dead Redemption 2 unfolds, Arthur Morgan meets his demise, and with him, his horses disappear. When John Marston takes over as the main protagonist, he doesn’t inherit Arthur’s horses. This means that all the horses Arthur owned, including the unique and valuable ones, are lost forever.

Why Can’t John Keep Arthur’s Horses?

There are a few reasons why John Marston can’t keep Arthur’s horses. Firstly, Arthur’s horses are considered his personal property, and when he dies, they become part of his estate. As John Marston, he is not entitled to inherit these horses as they are not part of his own property.

What Happens to Buell?

One notable exception is Buell, the horse Arthur gave to John Marston after a mission in Chapter 6. However, even in this case, Buell is not inherited by John Marston. Instead, John must complete the remaining part of Hamish Sinclair’s mission to keep Buell as his own. If John fails to do so, Buell will also disappear, leaving John to start from scratch with his own horses.

Other Horses Not Transferable

Unfortunately, John Marston cannot keep any of Arthur’s other horses, including the unique and valuable ones. These horses are lost forever, leaving John to start from scratch with his own horses. This means that John Marston will have to focus on building his own stables and acquiring new horses to aid him in his adventures.

Table of Arthur’s Horses That Can’t Be Kept

Conclusion

In conclusion, unfortunately, John Marston cannot keep Arthur’s horses as his own. These horses are considered part of Arthur’s estate and disappear when he passes away. While John Marston will have to start from scratch with his own horses, he will still have access to a wide range of horse breeds and types to choose from.