Could Arthur have killed Micah without TB?

Could Arthur Have Killed Micah Without TB?

The question on everyone’s mind: Could Arthur Morgan, the iconic outlaw from Red Dead Redemption 2, have taken down Micah Bell, his treacherous and ruthless gang member, without contracting tuberculosis (TB)? In this article, we’ll delve into the events leading up to their final showdown and explore the possibilities of Arthur’s chances of killing Micah without TB.

The Events Leading Up to the Showdown

Before we dive into the possibilities, let’s revisit the events that led up to the final confrontation between Arthur and Micah. Micah, who had previously betrayed the gang and their leader, Dutch Van der Linde, had come back to the gang’s camp, seeking revenge against Arthur, who had stood up to him and denied his request to join their gang. Micah, fueled by anger and resentment, had been planning to take down Arthur and assert his dominance.

The Final Confrontation

The final showdown between Arthur and Micah took place in the abandoned mine near the gang’s camp. Micah, armed with a revolver, had already taken out several gang members, including Hosea and Susan, and was on his way to take down Arthur. Arthur, already weakened by his TB diagnosis, was determined to stop Micah and put an end to his reign of terror.

Could Arthur Have Killed Micah Without TB?

So, could Arthur have killed Micah without TB? According to the game’s lore, Arthur’s TB weakened his immune system, making him more susceptible to other illnesses and infections. However, it’s also important to note that Arthur was an exceptional marksman and fighter, even without TB. In a one-on-one confrontation, Arthur’s skills and training would have given him an advantage over Micah, who was not as experienced in hand-to-hand combat.

Arthur’s Advantages

Here are some advantages Arthur had that would have given him an edge in a fight against Micah:

• Expert marksmanship: Arthur was an expert shot and could have taken out Micah from a distance with ease.
• Close-quarters combat skills: Despite his weakened state, Arthur was still a skilled fighter and could have taken on Micah in close-quarters combat.
• Agility and quick reflexes: Arthur’s agility and quick reflexes would have allowed him to dodge Micah’s attacks and land some devastating blows.

Micah’s Disadvantages

On the other hand, Micah had some significant disadvantages that would have made it difficult for him to take down Arthur:

• Limited marksmanship skills: Micah was not as skilled a shot as Arthur, which would have put him at a disadvantage in a standoff.
• Aggressive fighting style: Micah’s aggressive fighting style often left him open to counterattacks, which Arthur could have taken advantage of.
• Lack of experience in close-quarters combat: Micah was more comfortable with ranged combat, which would have made him vulnerable in close-quarters situations.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while Arthur’s TB weakened his immune system and made him more vulnerable to infection, it didn’t necessarily mean he would have lost the fight against Micah. With his exceptional marksmanship and close-quarters combat skills, Arthur would have had the upper hand in a one-on-one confrontation. However, it’s important to note that the game’s story is designed to create a sense of tension and uncertainty, and the outcome of the final confrontation was always intended to be the tragic conclusion it was.

Table: Arthur vs. Micah: Who Would Have Won?

In the end, while Arthur’s TB may have made the fight more challenging, it wasn’t the deciding factor. Arthur’s skills, training, and experience would have given him the advantage in a fight against Micah.