Did Elden Ring copy breath of the wild?

Did Elden Ring Copy Breath of the Wild?

Elden Ring, the highly anticipated action role-playing game developed by FromSoftware, has been making waves in the gaming community with its stunning visuals, intricate world design, and engaging gameplay mechanics. However, some critics have raised questions about the game’s originality, with some arguing that it borrowed heavily from The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild. In this article, we’ll delve into the similarities and differences between the two games to determine whether Elden Ring copied Breath of the Wild.

The Director’s Take

Hidetaka Miyazaki, the director of Elden Ring, has acknowledged the influence of various games, including Breath of the Wild, on the development of his game. In an interview, Miyazaki mentioned that he and his team drew inspiration from several sources, including Shadow of the Colossus, The Elder Scrolls series, and The Witcher 3. While he didn’t specifically mention Breath of the Wild, it’s clear that the game’s open-world design and exploration mechanics have some similarities with those found in Breath of the Wild.

Similarities Between Elden Ring and Breath of the Wild

• Open-world design: Both games feature vast, open worlds that players can explore at their own pace. Elden Ring’s world, known as the Lands Between, is a vast, interconnected realm filled with hidden secrets and mysteries, while Breath of the Wild’s Hyrule is a sprawling landscape with its own secrets and surprises.
• Exploration mechanics: Both games encourage players to explore and discover new locations, secrets, and enemies. Elden Ring’s exploration mechanics include a complex network of underground tunnels and hidden areas, while Breath of the Wild’s exploration mechanics involve climbing, gliding, and using various tools to reach new areas.
• Combat systems: Both games feature complex combat systems that require players to use strategy and tactics to overcome enemies. Elden Ring’s combat system is built around the player’s ability to use a variety of weapons and abilities to take down enemies, while Breath of the Wild’s combat system is centered around the player’s ability to use the environment to their advantage.

Differences Between Elden Ring and Breath of the Wild

• Storytelling: While both games feature complex, interconnected stories, Elden Ring’s narrative is more focused on the player’s character and their journey, while Breath of the Wild’s story is more focused on the world and its history.
• Gameplay mechanics: Elden Ring’s gameplay mechanics are more focused on combat and exploration, while Breath of the Wild’s gameplay mechanics are more focused on exploration and puzzle-solving.
• Art style: Elden Ring’s art style is more dark and gothic, with a focus on atmospheric lighting and textures, while Breath of the Wild’s art style is more colorful and vibrant, with a focus on detailed environments and characters.

Conclusion

While Elden Ring may have borrowed some inspiration from Breath of the Wild, it’s clear that the game is more than just a copycat. FromSoftware’s dedication to creating a unique and engaging gaming experience is evident in every aspect of the game, from its intricate world design to its complex combat mechanics. Ultimately, Elden Ring is a game that stands on its own merits, and fans of both action RPGs and open-world adventures will find plenty to love about it.

Key Takeaways

• Elden Ring’s director, Hidetaka Miyazaki, has acknowledged the influence of various games, including Breath of the Wild, on the development of the game.
• Both games feature open-world design and exploration mechanics, but Elden Ring’s world is more complex and interconnected.
• Elden Ring’s combat system is more focused on player agency and strategy, while Breath of the Wild’s combat system is more focused on using the environment to the player’s advantage.
• Elden Ring’s art style is more dark and gothic, while Breath of the Wild’s art style is more colorful and vibrant.

Table: Similarities and Differences Between Elden Ring and Breath of the Wild

Bullets List: Key Features of Elden Ring and Breath of the Wild

• Elden Ring:
  • Complex world design with hidden secrets and mysteries
  • Intricate combat mechanics with a focus on player agency
  • Exploration mechanics that encourage players to discover new locations and secrets
  • Dark and gothic art style with atmospheric lighting and textures
• Breath of the Wild:
  • Open-world design with a focus on exploration and discovery
  • Combat mechanics that encourage players to use the environment to their advantage
  • Puzzle-solving mechanics that require players to think creatively
  • Colorful and vibrant art style with detailed environments and characters