Does Banefire work on indestructible?

Does Banefire Work on Indestructible?

Banefire is a popular Magic: The Gathering card that deals damage to all creatures. But what happens when an indestructible creature is on the battlefield? Can Banefire still deal damage to it? In this article, we’ll dive into the details and provide a comprehensive answer to this question.

Direct Answer:

Yes, Banefire can deal damage to an indestructible creature. Indestructible only prevents "destroy" effects and lethal damage, not damage from spells like Banefire.

Understanding Indestructible:

Indestructible is a keyword ability that prevents a creature from being destroyed by "destroy" effects. This means that an indestructible creature can’t be killed by spells like Devastation Tide or Crush of Tentacles. However, indestructible doesn’t protect the creature from damage from other sources, such as spells like Banefire or Fireball.

How Banefire Works:

Banefire is a sorcery that deals X damage to all creatures, where X is the value chosen by the player. When a player casts Banefire, they choose a value for X and the spell resolves immediately. Banefire’s effect is not a "destroy" effect, so it’s not affected by indestructible.

Example Scenario:

Suppose an indestructible creature with 5 toughness is on the battlefield. An opponent casts Banefire with a value of 3. The creature will take 3 damage from Banefire, but it won’t be destroyed because of its indestructible ability.

Other Spells That Can Deal Damage to Indestructible Creatures:

While Banefire can deal damage to indestructible creatures, there are other spells that can also do so. Here are a few examples:

• Fireball: This spell deals 3 damage to any target, which includes indestructible creatures.
• Lightning Bolt: This spell deals 3 damage to any target, including indestructible creatures.
• Goblin Bomb: This spell deals 5 damage to any target, including indestructible creatures.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, Banefire can deal damage to indestructible creatures. Indestructible only prevents "destroy" effects and lethal damage, not damage from spells like Banefire. While Banefire can deal damage to indestructible creatures, there are other spells that can also do so. When building a deck, it’s essential to consider the potential interactions between cards and plan accordingly.

Additional Tips:

• Countering Banefire: If you have a spell that can counter Banefire, such as Counterspell or Mana Leak, you can use it to prevent Banefire from resolving and dealing damage to your creatures.
• Removing Indestructible Creatures: If you have a spell that can remove indestructible creatures, such as Path to Exile or Supplanter, you can use it to get rid of an indestructible creature that’s on the battlefield.
• Building a Deck Around Banefire: If you’re building a deck around Banefire, consider including other spells that can deal damage to indestructible creatures, such as Fireball or Lightning Bolt. You should also consider including spells that can remove indestructible creatures or counter Banefire itself.

I hope this article has been helpful in answering your question about whether Banefire works on indestructible creatures. Remember to always keep in mind the potential interactions between cards and plan accordingly when building a deck. Happy gaming!