Does Fog Stop Commander Damage?
In the world of Magic: The Gathering, Commander is a popular format that allows players to build their own decks and compete against each other. One of the most important rules in Commander is the concept of Commander damage, which is damage dealt to a player by their opponent’s Commander. But what happens when a player uses Fog, a popular spell that prevents all combat damage? Does Fog stop Commander damage?
The Simple Answer
The simple answer is no, Fog does not stop Commander damage. According to the official Magic: The Gathering rules, Commander damage is a specific type of damage that is dealt to a player by their opponent’s Commander, regardless of whether or not the Commander is blocked or not. Fog, on the other hand, prevents all combat damage, which includes regular combat damage, but not Commander damage.
The Rules of Commander Damage
To understand why Fog does not stop Commander damage, we need to look at the rules of Commander damage. According to the official Magic: The Gathering rules, Commander damage is dealt to a player by their opponent’s Commander whenever that Commander is on the battlefield and the player has been dealt 21 or more combat damage by that Commander over the course of the game. The damage is not reduced or prevented by any means, including Fog.
The Difference Between Combat Damage and Commander Damage
It’s important to note that there is a difference between combat damage and Commander damage. Combat damage is damage dealt to a player by a creature or other attacking creature, while Commander damage is damage dealt to a player by their opponent’s Commander. Fog prevents all combat damage, but not Commander damage.
Examples and Scenarios
To illustrate the difference between combat damage and Commander damage, let’s look at a few examples and scenarios:
- Scenario 1: A player uses Fog to prevent all combat damage. Their opponent’s Commander, a 4/4 creature, attacks them. The Fog prevents the Commander from dealing any combat damage to the player. However, the Commander still deals Commander damage to the player, because it is not blocked and the player has been dealt 21 or more combat damage by the Commander over the course of the game.
- Scenario 2: A player’s Commander, a 2/2 creature, is attacked by their opponent’s Commander, a 4/4 creature. The player uses Fog to prevent all combat damage. The Fog prevents the opponent’s Commander from dealing any combat damage to the player, but the player’s Commander still deals Commander damage to the opponent, because it is not blocked and the opponent has been dealt 21 or more combat damage by the Commander over the course of the game.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Fog does not stop Commander damage. Commander damage is a specific type of damage that is dealt to a player by their opponent’s Commander, regardless of whether or not the Commander is blocked or not. Fog prevents all combat damage, but not Commander damage. Players who want to protect themselves from Commander damage should use other means, such as using a Commander that has a built-in ability to prevent damage or using a spell that specifically prevents Commander damage.
Table: Commander Damage vs. Combat Damage
| Commander Damage | Combat Damage | |
|---|---|---|
| Prevented by Fog | No | Yes |
| Dealt by Commander | Yes | No |
| Reduces life total | Yes | Yes |
Key Takeaways
- Fog does not stop Commander damage.
- Commander damage is a specific type of damage that is dealt to a player by their opponent’s Commander.
- Combat damage is damage dealt to a player by a creature or other attacking creature.
- Fog prevents all combat damage, but not Commander damage.
- Players who want to protect themselves from Commander damage should use other means, such as using a Commander that has a built-in ability to prevent damage or using a spell that specifically prevents Commander damage.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X5Q9-iYkYmo