Does glittering wish work in Commander?

Does Glittering Wish Work in Commander?

As we dive into the world of Commander, we’re often faced with the age-old question: can traditional cards work in this specific format? One such card that has sparked debate among players is Glittering Wish. In this article, we’ll delve into the intricacies of the Commander format and explore whether Glittering Wish truly works in this competitive landscape.

Commander 101: A Quick Recap

Before we dive into the meat of the topic, let’s take a step back and quickly revisit the basics of Commander. For those new to the format, Commander is a type of Magic: The Gathering game where players construct decks around a specific "commander" card, which serves as the "leader" of the deck. Each player’s commander card is unique and determines the colors of the cards they can play.

In a Commander game, each player starts with a deck of 100 cards and has the goal of reducing the opponent’s life total from 40 to 0. Sounds simple, but it’s not – it requires strategy, planning, and a healthy dose of creativity.

What Makes Glittering Wish so Special?

Glittering Wish is a notoriously tricky card to play around with. On the surface, it seems like a simple wish card that lets you grab any permanent (not including creatures) from your sideboard and add it to the game. Simple enough, right? However, there’s a catch – and it’s one that makes Glittering Wish a game-changer in Commander.

What About the Sideboard?

Ah, yes, the sideboard. As you may know, the Commander format does not have a traditional sideboard. This is because the sideboard, by design, is meant to be a way for players to swap out cards in between matches, much like in a constructed format like Modern or Standard.

However, this poses an issue for Glittering Wish, which explicitly mentions "sideboard" as a possible source for the permanent to be added to the game. In Commander, the sideboard is simply nonexistent, making it seem as though Glittering Wish wouldn’t work as intended.

Commander Rule 0 to the Rescue!

Enter Commander Rule 0, the official unofficial rule that allows players to modify the gamestate in non-competitive environments. Essentially, this means that players can agree upon modifications to the rules prior to the game, which allows for flexibility and creative liberties.

In this case, players can use Rule 0 to modify the sideboard concept to make it applicable to the Commander format. This effectively turns the Commander’s library (which is usually referred to as the "deck") into a de facto sideboard, allowing players to swap out cards in and out of the game.

So, Does Glittering Wish Work in Commander?

Now that we’ve addressed the major roadblock, the answer becomes clear: Glittering Wish can, in fact, work in Commander. However, there are some caveats to consider:

• The card’s intended usage: Glittering Wish is designed to work around a traditional sideboard. To make it work in Commander, players will need to adapt the card’s intended usage to fit the Commander format.
• Rulings and disputes: With Commander Rule 0 at play, disputes and arguments can arise regarding the validity of the modified ruleset. Players must agree on the modifications prior to the game to avoid conflicts.
• Creativity and resourcefulness: Commander players are known for their cunning and resourcefulness. In this case, they will need to be creative with how they use Glittering Wish, as well as how they build around it.

In Conclusion…

Glittering Wish, despite its origins in a traditional Magic setting, can indeed work in the Commander format. With the flexibility provided by Commander Rule 0, players can adapt the card’s intended usage to fit the unique needs of this format.

Whether you’re an old-school Commander veteran or a newcomer to the world of Magic, the discussion surrounding Glittering Wish in Commander serves as a testament to the creative problem-solving and resourcefulness of Magic players.