Does it Matter Who I Give Fire Keeper Soul to?
In the world of Dark Souls, the Fire Keeper Soul is a valuable item that can be used to upgrade the Estus flask, which is essential for any adventurer. However, many players are unsure about who they should give the Fire Keeper Soul to. In this article, we will explore the options and provide you with the best choice.
Who are the Fire Keepers?
Before we dive into the answer, let’s first talk about who the Fire Keepers are. In Dark Souls, there are three Fire Keepers that can be found in the game: Anastacia of Astora, the mute girl in the cell below Firelink Shrine, and the brass armored Fire Keeper at the main bonfire in Anor Londo. Each of these Fire Keepers has their own unique abilities and characteristics.
What Happens if I Give the Fire Keeper Soul to Each Fire Keeper?
Now that we know who the Fire Keepers are, let’s take a look at what happens if you give the Fire Keeper Soul to each of them.
| Fire Keeper | Effect of Giving Fire Keeper Soul |
|---|---|
| Anastacia of Astora | Upgrades the Estus flask |
| Mute Girl in the Cell | Consumes the soul, giving you some humanity, souls, and full healing |
| Brass Armored Fire Keeper | Consumes the soul, giving you some humanity, souls, and full healing |
As you can see, each Fire Keeper has a unique effect when given the Fire Keeper Soul. Anastacia of Astora upgrades the Estus flask, which is a crucial item for any adventurer. The mute girl in the cell consumes the soul, giving you some humanity, souls, and full healing, which can be useful in certain situations. The brass armored Fire Keeper also consumes the soul, giving you some humanity, souls, and full healing, but this option is not as beneficial as the others.
Why Does it Matter Who I Give the Fire Keeper Soul to?
So, why does it matter who you give the Fire Keeper Soul to? Well, the answer is that it doesn’t really matter. Yes, you read that right. While each Fire Keeper has a unique effect, they are all ultimately just consuming the soul and giving you some benefits. The real question is what benefits do you want?
Should I Give the Fire Keeper Soul to Anastacia of Astora?
If you’re looking to upgrade your Estus flask, then Anastacia of Astora is the way to go. Upgrading the Estus flask will give you more uses for the flask, which can be crucial in certain situations. For example, if you’re exploring a dark and ominous area, having more uses for your Estus flask can be a lifesaver.
Should I Give the Fire Keeper Soul to the Mute Girl in the Cell?
If you’re looking for a quick way to gain some humanity, souls, and full healing, then the mute girl in the cell is a good option. Consuming the soul with her will give you these benefits, which can be useful in certain situations.
Should I Give the Fire Keeper Soul to the Brass Armored Fire Keeper?
If you’re looking for a way to gain some humanity, souls, and full healing, then the brass armored Fire Keeper is an option. However, as mentioned earlier, this option is not as beneficial as the others. Consuming the soul with her will give you these benefits, but it’s not as useful as upgrading your Estus flask or gaining humanity, souls, and full healing through other means.
Conclusion
In conclusion, whether or not it matters who you give the Fire Keeper Soul to ultimately depends on what benefits you want. If you want to upgrade your Estus flask, then Anastacia of Astora is the way to go. If you want to gain some humanity, souls, and full healing, then the mute girl in the cell or the brass armored Fire Keeper are options. However, it’s important to remember that these benefits can be gained through other means as well.