Is Bartleby a villain?

Is Bartleby a Villain?

The protagonist of Herman Melville’s novella, Bartleby, the Scrivener, is a peculiar character who has sparked various interpretations among readers and critics. While some view Bartleby as a relatable and sympathetic figure, others see him as a villain who causes chaos and destruction. In this article, we will delve into the complexities of Bartleby’s character and argue that he is, indeed, a villain.

The Antagonist in the Narrative

Bartleby’s role as the antagonist in the novella is evident from the beginning. He is described as a mysterious and awkward individual who is hired to work as a scrivener in a law firm. Initially, he appears to be a diligent employee, but soon, his apathy and reluctance to work become apparent. Despite the narrator’s efforts to reason with him, Bartleby’s behavior only worsens, leading to a series of conflicts that ultimately result in his departure from the firm.

Bartleby’s Passive-Aggressive Nature

One of the key characteristics that define Bartleby’s villainous nature is his passive-aggressive behavior. He consistently says "I would prefer not to" when faced with tasks or responsibilities, demonstrating a refusal to engage or cooperate. This phrase, which becomes a refrain throughout the novella, highlights Bartleby’s laziness and lack of accountability. By refusing to acknowledge his duties, Bartleby is able to externalize his problems and blame others for his own lack of effort.

Sabotaging the Law Firm

Bartleby’s behavior has a profound impact on the law firm, causing chaos and disorder. His refusal to work leads to a backlog of work, which in turn affects the firm’s productivity and reputation. The narrator, who is initially tolerant of Bartleby’s behavior, becomes increasingly frustrated and helpless as the situation spirals out of control. Bartleby’s actions are not only damaging to the firm but also to the other employees who are affected by his presence.

Bartleby’s Death: A Symbol of His Failure

The novella concludes with Bartleby’s death, which is a powerful symbol of his failure. Having been arrested and imprisoned, Bartleby is found dead in his cell, having starved himself to death. This ending can be seen as a result of Bartleby’s own actions, which were motivated by his refusal to engage with the world around him. His death serves as a reminder of the consequences of his inaction and the devastating impact it has on those around him.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Bartleby can be seen as a villain due to his passive-aggressive nature, his sabotage of the law firm, and his ultimate failure, which results in his death. While some may argue that Bartleby’s character is sympathetic and relatable, his actions demonstrate a clear lack of responsibility and accountability. As we reflect on the novella, it is clear that Bartleby’s character serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of complacency and the importance of taking action in the face of adversity.

Important Points:

  • Bartleby’s Passive-Aggressive Behavior: His refusal to work and engage with the world around him is a clear indicator of his villainous nature.
  • Sabotaging the Law Firm: Bartleby’s actions have a profound impact on the law firm, causing chaos and disorder.
  • Bartleby’s Death: His death serves as a powerful symbol of his failure and the consequences of his inaction.

Table: Bartleby’s Behavior and Its Consequences

Behavior Consequences
Refusal to work Backlog of work, chaos and disorder in the law firm
Passive-aggressive nature Frustration and helplessness among the other employees
Sabotaging the law firm Negative impact on the firm’s reputation and productivity
Failure to engage with the world Death and devastating impact on those around him

Bullets: Bartleby’s Traits and Characteristics

• Passive-aggressive behavior
• Refusal to work or engage with the world around him
• Sabotaging the law firm and causing chaos and disorder
• Lack of accountability and responsibility
• Failure to take action in the face of adversity

Your friends have asked us these questions - Check out the answers!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top