Is Great Weapon Fighting Better with Greatsword or Greataxe?
When it comes to great weapon fighting, paladins and fighters can choose between two formidable weapons: the greatsword and the greataxe. Both weapons have their own strengths and weaknesses, making it essential to determine which one is better suited for great weapon fighting.
Average Damage
According to various sources, a greatsword deals slightly more damage overall than a greataxe. On a normal hit, a greatsword averages 8.33 damage, while a greataxe averages 7.33 damage. However, on a critical hit, the damage is doubled in both cases, resulting in a higher average damage output.
| Weapon | Normal Hit Damage | Critical Hit Damage | Average Damage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Greatsword | 8.33 | 16.66 | 12.5 |
| Greataxe | 7.33 | 14.66 | 11.01 |
Rolling for Damage
Rolling for damage is another critical aspect of great weapon fighting. A d6 is used for the greatsword, while a d12 is used for the greataxe. A higher die roll can result in higher damage output.
| Die Roll | Probability |
|---|---|
| Greatsword (d6) | 0-6 |
| Greataxe (d12) | 0-12 |
Greatsword Benefits
- Deals more average damage than the greataxe
- Easier to hit with (d6 has a smaller range than d12)
Greataxe Benefits
- Can deal critical hits more easily (since a 6 or 7 on a d12 can still result in a critical hit)
- Higher maximum damage potential (14.66)
Choosing the Right Weapon
Based on the above analysis, a greatsword may be a better choice for a paladin or fighter who:
- Values consistent and reliable damage output
- Is likely to hit often
- Doesn’t rely on critical hits for their damage output
On the other hand, a greataxe may be a better choice for a paladin or fighter who:
- Needs to deal critical hits more often
- Can rely on their opponent not being as likely to dodge their attacks
- Values the potential for high maximum damage output
In Conclusion
In the end, the choice between a greatsword and a greataxe for great weapon fighting comes down to the individual playstyle and needs of the paladin or fighter. Both weapons have their own strengths and weaknesses, and understanding those strengths and weaknesses is key to making the right decision. Whether you choose a greatsword or a greataxe, remember that practice and skill are key to making the most of your weapon choice.