Should I do Whispering Hillock before Ladies of the Wood?
The Whispering Hillock and Ladies of the Wood are two critical quests in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. While it’s not possible to fully resolve the fate of everyone in the Crookback Bog without completing these quests, you can still make decisions that impact the story and characters. In this article, we’ll explore the implications of completing Whispering Hillock before or after Ladies of the Wood.
Spoiler Alert: This article contains spoilers for the Whispering Hillock and Ladies of the Wood quests.
What Happens If You Complete Whispering Hillock Before Ladies of the Wood?
If you complete Whispering Hillock before talking to the Crones and completing Ladies of the Wood, you’ll essentially prevent the murders of the village children. This means Anna, the Baron, and the children will all be saved. However, the villagers of Downwarren will still die, as freeing the spirit means they’ll be cursed to an early grave.
Here’s a breakdown of the possible outcomes:
| Character | Fate |
|---|---|
| Anna | Alive |
| Baron | Alive |
| Village Children | Alive |
| Villagers of Downwarren | Die due to curse |
What Happens If You Complete Ladies of the Wood First?
On the other hand, if you complete Ladies of the Wood first, you’ll have to kill the tree spirit to save the village children. This means Anna and the Baron will both die, but the villagers will be spared. However, the children will still die.
Here’s a breakdown of the possible outcomes:
| Character | Fate |
|---|---|
| Anna | Dies |
| Baron | Dies |
| Village Children | Die |
| Villagers of Downwarren | Live |
Which Choice Is Better?
Ultimately, there’s no right or wrong answer here. The decision comes down to personal preference and what kind of story you want to tell. If you’re invested in saving as many characters as possible, completing Whispering Hillock first might be the better choice. However, if you’re willing to make difficult decisions and see the story unfold naturally, completing Ladies of the Wood first could be a better option.
Tips for Making the Most of Your Decision
- Save your game before making a decision: This will allow you to experiment with different choices without losing progress.
- Consider the lore: The Whispering Hillock and Ladies of the Wood are both tied to the mysterious and often brutal world of the Continent. Consider what kind of story you want to tell and how your choices fit into that narrative.
- Play with an open mind: Be prepared to encounter unexpected consequences or moral dilemmas, and be open to changing your approach as needed.
Conclusion
Ultimately, whether you choose to complete Whispering Hillock before or after Ladies of the Wood, the fate of the characters in the Crookback Bog will be significantly impacted. By considering the potential outcomes and thinking critically about your choices, you can make the most of this pivotal moment in The Witcher 3’s story. Remember to save your game, consider the lore, and be open to unexpected outcomes.