Should I give back the Golden Claw?

Should I Give Back the Golden Claw?

In the world of Skyrim, the Golden Claw is a highly coveted item that grants immense power to its possessor. But the question remains: should you give it back? In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of retaining the Golden Claw and provide you with the best decision based on your in-game situation.

Why Keep the Golden Claw?

Here are some compelling reasons to keep the Golden Claw:

• Increased Gold: The Golden Claw is worth a significant amount of gold, which can be used to purchase valuable items, upgrades, and skills.

• Convenience: Having the Golden Claw allows you to open the door to Bleak Falls Barrow, granting access to a powerful and lucrative treasure trove.

• Influence: As a member of the Thieves Guild, retaining the Golden Claw demonstrates your loyalty and expertise, earning you the respect and admiration of your guildmates.

• Power: The Golden Claw, when wielded, can give you a significant edge in combat, making you a formidable opponent on the battlefield.

Why Return the Golden Claw?

On the other hand, there are strong arguments for returning the Golden Claw:

• Karma: Giving back the Golden Claw aligns with your moral compass and reflects positively on your character’s values.

• Lucan Valerius: By returning the Golden Claw, you demonstrate your integrity and commitment to the Thieves Guild, potentially gaining Lucan’s respect and trust.

• Less Drama: Retaining the Golden Claw may lead to repercussions, including hostility from the people of Riverwood and potential faction strife. Returning it avoids this drama.

When Should I Make My Decision?

The decision to keep or return the Golden Claw is influenced by several factors:

• In-Game Situation: Consider the state of your game: Are you in need of gold or resources? Are you on good terms with Lucan and the Thieves Guild? This context can guide your decision.

• Your Character’s Morality: If your character values honor, integrity, and loyalty, returning the Golden Claw may be the more honorable choice. If you prioritize personal gain and convenience, retaining the Golden Claw might be more appealing.

Key Considerations

When deciding what to do with the Golden Claw, keep these points in mind:

• Talk to Lucan Valerius: Discussing the situation with Lucan can provide valuable insight and may even offer an alternative solution.

• Consult Your Journal: Reviewing your journal may reveal hints or clues about the Golden Claw’s history and significance, which can influence your decision.

The Verdict

In conclusion, whether you should give back the Golden Claw or retain it ultimately depends on your in-game situation, character values, and personal preferences. Consider the pros and cons carefully and make a decision that aligns with your gameplay and role-playing goals.

Recommendations

If you:

• Are a loyal member of the Thieves Guild and prioritize its values: Return the Golden Claw.

• Are in need of gold or resources and value convenience: Keep the Golden Claw.

• Are on good terms with Lucan and value your relationship: Return the Golden Claw.

• Prioritize your character’s moral compass: Return the Golden Claw.

By considering these factors and weighing the pros and cons, you can make an informed decision that best suits your Skyrim adventure.