Should I Give Ember to Mcduff?
As you progress through the Dark Souls series, you’ll come across various blacksmiths who can upgrade your weapons. One of the most important blacksmiths is Mcduff, the blacksmith in the High Wall of Lothric. Mcduff requires a Dull Ember to infuse your weapons with various elements, making them more powerful. But the question remains: should you give Mcduff the Dull Ember?
The Benefits of Giving Ember to Mcduff
There are several benefits to giving the Dull Ember to Mcduff:
- Infuse Your Weapons with Elements: Mcduff can infuse your weapons with elements such as fire, lightning, and poison, making them more effective against certain enemies and in certain situations.
- Increase Your Weapon’s Damage: Infusing your weapons with elements can significantly increase their damage output, making them more effective in combat.
- Access to New Abilities: Some weapons can only be infused with certain elements, allowing you to access new abilities and playstyles.
The Drawbacks of Giving Ember to Mcduff
However, there are also some drawbacks to consider:
- Limited Ember Availability: The Dull Ember is a rare and limited resource, and giving it to Mcduff may leave you without a backup option.
- Other Blacksmiths May Need It: Other blacksmiths in the game, such as Andre, may also require the Dull Ember to infuse weapons. Giving it to Mcduff may leave these blacksmiths unable to fulfill their tasks.
- Alternative Options: There may be alternative options for infusing your weapons, such as using different items or finding other blacksmiths who can do the job.
Who Else Can Use the Dull Ember?
While Mcduff is the most prominent blacksmith who can use the Dull Ember, there are other characters who may also require it:
- Andre the Blacksmith: Andre, the blacksmith in Anor Londo, can use the Dull Ember to infuse your weapons with elements such as fire, lightning, and poison.
- Giant Blacksmith: The Giant Blacksmith in the Undead Settlement can use the Dull Ember to infuse your weapons with elements such as fire, lightning, and poison.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the decision to give the Dull Ember to Mcduff is up to you. If you want to infuse your weapons with elements and increase their damage output, then giving the ember to Mcduff may be the best option. However, if you’re concerned about the limited availability of the ember or want to explore alternative options, then you may want to consider other blacksmiths who can use the ember.