Should I Give Gideon the Potion?
As you navigate the world of Elden Ring, you’ll come across various choices that can impact the game’s outcome. One of these choices is whether to give Gideon the potion or not. In this article, we’ll dive into the pros and cons of giving Gideon the potion and help you make an informed decision.
Why Give Gideon the Potion?
Giving Gideon the potion may seem like a simple decision, but it has significant consequences. Here are some reasons why you might want to give Gideon the potion:
- Rewards: Giving Gideon the potion earns you the Dolores puppet Spirit summon, which can be a valuable asset in your journey.
- Quest Completion: Completing the quest for Gideon rewards you with items and experience points.
- Alternative Ending: Giving Gideon the potion allows you to progress through the story and access new areas and quests.
Why Not Give Gideon the Potion?
On the other hand, there are reasons why you might not want to give Gideon the potion:
- Losing Access to Nepehli’s Quest: Giving Gideon the potion locks you out of Nepehli’s quest, which may be an important part of your story progression.
- Potential Consequences: Some players believe that giving Gideon the potion has unintended consequences, such as causing harm to other characters or altering the game’s story.
- Alternative Path: Not giving Gideon the potion allows you to explore alternative paths and quests, which may be more appealing to some players.
When to Give Gideon the Potion?
If you decide to give Gideon the potion, there are specific circumstances under which you should do so:
- After Completing the Quest: Make sure you’ve completed the quest for Gideon before giving him the potion, as this ensures you’ll receive the rewards.
- After Talking to Nepheli: Talk to Nepheli under the bridge in the Village of Albaniurics to progress the story and unlock the option to give Gideon the potion.
When Not to Give Gideon the Potion?
On the other hand, there are situations where you might not want to give Gideon the potion:
- Before Completing the Quest: Don’t give Gideon the potion before completing the quest, as this will prevent you from receiving the rewards.
- After Killing the Dung Eater: Some players believe that killing the Dung Eater has unintended consequences, so it’s best to avoid giving Gideon the potion if you’ve done so.
Conclusion
Giving Gideon the potion is a significant decision that can impact your progress in Elden Ring. While there are pros and cons to giving Gideon the potion, it ultimately depends on your playstyle and goals. Consider the rewards, quest completion, and potential consequences before making your decision. Remember to talk to Nepheli and complete the quest for Gideon before giving him the potion, and be mindful of the potential consequences of your actions.
FAQs
- What happens if I give Gideon the potion?: Giving Gideon the potion earns you the Dolores puppet Spirit summon and completes the quest.
- What are the consequences of not giving Gideon the potion?: Not giving Gideon the potion allows you to explore alternative paths and quests, but may prevent you from completing the quest.
- Can I change my mind after giving Gideon the potion?: Unfortunately, no. Once you give Gideon the potion, it’s irreversible.
Table: Pros and Cons of Giving Gideon the Potion
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Earns the Dolores puppet Spirit summon | Locks out Nepehli’s quest |
| Completes the quest | Potential unintended consequences |
| Rewards items and experience points | Alternative paths and quests may be more appealing |
I hope this article has helped you make an informed decision about whether to give Gideon the potion or not. Happy gaming!