Should I Give McDuff the Dull Ember?
Direct Answer: Yes, you should give McDuff the Dull Ember.
Why?
• McDuff is the only blacksmith who asks for the Dull Ember to infuse weapons with elemental properties.
• Giving McDuff the Dull Ember will allow you to access infusions, making your weapons more powerful and versatile.
• McDuff is the best blacksmith in the game, and his infusions are the most effective and useful.
What Happens if I Give Large Ember to Blacksmith?
• The Large Ember can be given to Andre the Blacksmith to allow him to modify +5 normal weapons to +10, and +5 raw.
• This is different from the Dull Ember, which is used by McDuff to infuse weapons with elemental properties.
• Giving the Large Ember to Andre will not give you access to infusions like McDuff’s.
Where Do I Get the Dull Ember?
• The Dull Ember is found in the Iron Keep, in a central room with a bridge.
• To obtain it, run across the bridge, turn right, jump the gap, and look towards the small staircase to the right.
• You can find the Dull Ember on a corpse in that room.
What is the Dull Ember Used For?
• The Dull Ember is used by McDuff to infuse weapons with elemental properties.
• This allows your weapons to have different elements, such as fire, lightning, or dark.
• Infused weapons can be more powerful and versatile than regular weapons.
Table: Comparison of McDuff and Andre’s Abilities
| McDuff | Andre | |
|---|---|---|
| Infusions | Infuses weapons with elemental properties | Modifies +5 normal weapons to +10, and +5 raw |
| Blacksmith | Best blacksmith in the game | Average blacksmith |
| Requirements | Dull Ember | Large Ember |
Conclusion
Giving McDuff the Dull Ember is the best decision for your character. McDuff is the best blacksmith in the game, and his infusions are the most effective and useful. With the Dull Ember, you can access infusions and make your weapons more powerful and versatile. Avoid giving the Large Ember to Andre, as it only allows him to modify normal weapons, and McDuff’s infusions are superior.