Should I give Millicent the needle?

Should I give Millicent the Needle?

In the intricate world of Elden Ring, deciding what to do with quests and items can be overwhelmingly daunting. One such enigmatic situation is the possibility of giving Millicent the needle. This item, known as Valkyrie’s Prosthesis, may seem insignificant at first but holds great significance in determining the fate of the demigod, Millicent, and the Scarlet Aeonia. In this article, we’ll delve into the decision-making process and explore the consequences of giving Millicent the needle.

What is Millicent’s Status?

Before diving into the question, it is essential to understand Millicent’s current situation in the game. If you haven’t cured Malenia of Scarlet Rot, Millicent is vulnerable to the disease and suffers from its effects. Interacting with her will require you to make a grave decision, which may greatly impact the story and NPC relationships.

What to Consider Before Giving the Needle

Before making a conclusion, it is crucial to weigh the pros and cons of giving Millicent the needle. Here’s a breakdown of the decision-making process:

In Favor of Giving the Needle:

• Salvaging Millicent: By giving her Valkyrie’s Prosthesis, you’ll remove the Scarlet Rot, returning her to her former status. This may allow the player to interact with Millicent without any disease-related consequences.
• Unlocking New Quest Options: Completing Millicent’s questline as intended may grant access to new storylines, lore, and potentially powerful loot.

Against Giving the Needle:

• Impact on NPC Relationships: Giving Millicent the needle may alter the perspective of other NPCs, **potentially leading to character changes or even death.* This could have significant ripples throughout the game.
• Alternative Questpath:** Withholding the needle may create an alternative adventure path, allowing for alternate storylines and encounters not accessible through the main quests.

The Consequences of Gifting Millicent’s Needle

If you elect to give Millicent the needle, the potential outcomes include:

Upon giving the needle, NPC reactions will vary. On one hand, Millicent’s health will likely return, and she will regain her former interactions; on the other hand, other NPCs may respond hostilely or even perish because of the altered circumstances. It is crucial to weigh the potential consequences thoroughly before making a decision

Conclusion

The conundrum of giving Millicent the needle stands as a testament to Elden Ring’s rich narratives and player agency. Although the choice may seem intimidating, considering the potential reactions and outcomes will ultimately be the key to a worthwhile experience. Remember, the consequences of your action will be felt throughout the game, so approach with caution and thoughtfulness before deciding what to do.