Should I Give Seluvis Potion to Gideon?
As you navigate the world of Elden Ring, you come across the enigmatic Seluvis, a character with multiple motives and allegiances. He hands you a potion, giving you a crucial decision to make: what to do with it. Should you give it to Gideon, the grumpy but ultimately helpful character, or should you opt for a different path? In this article, we’ll dive into the implications of your choice and provide guidance to help you make an informed decision.
What Are the Consequences of Giving the Potion to Gideon?
Reward: Continued Quests
• If you choose to give the potion to Gideon, you’ll still be able to progress with Nepheli’s questline, which means you’ll retain access to valuable rewards and story beats.
• This path also keeps the Dung Eater’s questline open, allowing you to continue exploring the lore and mechanics of Elden Ring.
Penalty: Losing Seluvis’ Favor
• Giving the potion to Gideon means you’ll miss out on Seluvis’ potential interactions and benefits. He’ll likely remain suspicious of you, making future encounters with him potentially more challenging.
Implications for Seluvis’ Quest
• By not giving Seluvis the potion, you’ll disrupt his original plan, potentially altering the trajectory of his quest.
• This may have unforeseen consequences for other characters and storylines in the game.
Is Gideon a Reliable Ally?
• Gideon, while gruff and initially unsympathetic, proves to be a loyal and helpful character throughout the game.
• His knowledge and skills are invaluable in navigating the world and overcoming challenges.
How to Approach Gideon with the Potion
• Speak with Gideon about the potion, and he’ll offer to take it from you.
• Make sure to ask him to dispose of the potion, ensuring Seluvis won’t be suspicious of your actions.
The Alternative: Not Giving the Potion to Gideon
• If you decide not to give the potion to Gideon, you’ll be forced to explore alternative options for its disposal.
• This path may lead to unforeseen consequences, as you’ll be altering Seluvis’ original plan and potentially impacting other characters.
Table: Summary of Consequences
| Consequence | Description |
|---|---|
| Reward: Continued Quests | You’ll be able to progress with Nepheli’s and Dung Eater’s quests. |
| Penalty: Losing Seluvis’ Favor | Seluvis will likely remain suspicious of you. |
| Disrupted Quest | Seluvis’ original plan is altered. |
Conclusion
When deciding whether to give the potion to Gideon, weigh the pros and cons carefully. On one hand, you’ll be preserving access to valuable quests and characters. On the other hand, you’ll be risking Seluvis’ favor and potentially disrupting the flow of the game’s story. Consider your overall goals and playstyle when making this choice. With careful consideration, you can make an informed decision that suits your journey in Elden Ring.
Recommended Course of Action
- Give the potion to Gideon, allowing you to continue with Nepheli’s and Dung Eater’s quests.
- Ask Gideon to dispose of the potion, ensuring Seluvis remains unaware of your actions.
Key Takeaways
- The potion is a critical item in Seluvis’ plan, and giving it to Gideon alters the course of his quest.
- Gideon is a reliable ally who can aid you in your journey.
- Disrupting Seluvis’ plan may have unforeseen consequences, so choose wisely.
By considering the consequences and implications of your decision, you’ll be well-equipped to make the best choice for your playthrough. Happy adventuring in the world of Elden Ring!