Should You Give the Large Ember to Andre?
In Dark Souls 3, acquiring the right embers at the right time can have a significant impact on the game’s progression. Embers, in particular, are essential for upgrading our weapons and equipment. Of the various embers that can be found in the game, the Large Ember is one of the most sought after. But a question arises: should I give the Large Ember to Andre?
What happens if you give the Large Ember to Andre?
If you give the Large Ember to Andre, Blacksmith in Firelink Shrine, he will be able to modify +5 regular weapons to +10 Dark, which is a fantastic upgrade for any player’s arsenal. This upgrade applies to a wide range of weapons, including swords, axes, and hammers. The Large Ember plays a crucial role in ensuring that Andre can perform these upgrades.
What would happen if you don’t give the Large Ember to Andre?
If you choose not to give the Large Ember to Andre, you’ll miss out on the opportunity to upgrade regular weapons to +10 Dark. While this might seem like a minor setback at first, it can restrict your build options and limits the diversity of your fighting style.
When Should You Give the Large Ember to Andre?
It is recommended to give the Large Ember to Andre as early as possible in the game. The sooner you grant him the ember, the sooner you’ll be able to access the upgraded upgrades. In fact, Blacksmith Andre is the primary source for upgrading weapons from +5 to +6, +7, all the way up to the maximum upgrade of +12.
What are Other Options for Upgrading Items?
While giving the Large Ember to Andre enables him to upgrade regular weapons to +10 Dark, that’s not the only means of upgrading items. Alternatively, you can use Ashen Estus to raise the number of Estus Flasks you can use. These flasks recharge your health, and upgraded Estus Flasks significantly enhance their effectiveness.
Furthermore, certain NPCs, including Vamos and Giant Blacksmith, can also apply unique upgrades to specific item categories. For instance, Vamos can upgrade +6 Fire weapons to +5 Chaos, while Giant Blacksmith can modify +8 Dark weapons to +3 Light. These upgrades demand specific embers, obtained through exploration and combat prowess.
Conclusion
There is no right or wrong answer when it comes to giving the Large Ember to Andre or not. However, offering the Large Ember to Andre comes with several benefits, ensuring that he can upgrade weapons to +10 Dark more efficiently. This upgrade paves the way for versatile builds, as you unlock new paths for your development. As you progress throughout the game, remember there are alternative options for updating items. Ultimately, experimenting with different upgrade paths opens up opportunities for unique loadouts and playstyles to emerge.