Should I give the Tonic of Forgetfulness or not?

Should I Give the Tonic of Forgetfulness or Not?

The Tonic of Forgetfulness is a special item in Elden Ring that can be used to alter the outcome of certain storylines. However, the decision of whether to use it or not is not an easy one, as it can have significant consequences on the game’s narrative and your character’s journey. In this article, we’ll explore the different options and outcomes of using the Tonic of Forgetfulness, and help you make an informed decision.

The Two Options

The Tonic of Forgetfulness can be used on two specific characters: Rya and Brother Corhyn. Here are the outcomes of using it on each of them:

The Consequences

Using the Tonic of Forgetfulness on Rya will lead to a new storyline branch, where she will no longer be involved in the game’s main quest. However, this decision will also mean that you’ll miss out on some of the game’s key story beats and character interactions.

Using the Tonic of Forgetfulness on Brother Corhyn will not have any significant consequences on the game’s narrative, but it will still allow you to obtain the item and potentially use it for other purposes in the future.

The Importance of Timing

The timing of when you use the Tonic of Forgetfulness is also crucial. You can only use it on Rya during a specific point in her storyline, and if you miss this opportunity, you’ll never be able to use it on her again.

The Alternatives

If you decide not to use the Tonic of Forgetfulness, you’ll still have the opportunity to interact with Rya and Brother Corhyn in other ways. For example, you can choose to spare Rya’s life and allow her to continue her quest, or you can defeat Brother Corhyn and obtain his set.

The Ultimate Decision

Ultimately, the decision of whether to use the Tonic of Forgetfulness or not is up to you. If you’re looking for a new storyline branch and are willing to miss out on some of the game’s key story beats, then using it on Rya might be the right choice for you. However, if you want to maintain the game’s original narrative and character interactions, then using it on Brother Corhyn or choosing not to use it at all might be the better option.

Conclusion

The Tonic of Forgetfulness is a powerful item in Elden Ring that can have significant consequences on the game’s narrative and your character’s journey. By understanding the different options and outcomes, you can make an informed decision about whether to use it or not. Whether you choose to use it on Rya, Brother Corhyn, or not at all, the choice is ultimately yours.