Should I Have Killed the Dung Eater?
The question of whether to kill or spare the Dung Eater is a crucial one in Elden Ring, and the answer depends on your playstyle and goals. In this article, we’ll delve into the implications of killing or sparing the Dung Eater, exploring the pros and cons of each decision.
The Dung Eater’s Questline
Before we dive into the decision, let’s quickly recap the Dung Eater’s questline. The Dung Eater is a serial killer who is obsessed with spreading his Seedbed Curses to every living being in the Lands Between. He’s a morally reprehensible character, and it’s tempting to kill him for his heinous actions.
The Reward of Sparing the Dung Eater
If you spare the Dung Eater, you’ll be rewarded with the Mending Rune of the Fell Curse, which is used to unlock an ending in Elden Ring. This ending, known as the "Blessing of Despair," is often considered one of the worst endings in the game. However, some players may be interested in exploring this dark and twisted ending.
The Consequences of Killing the Dung Eater
On the other hand, if you kill the Dung Eater, you’ll be rewarded with the Omen armor set, which increases Omen Bairn damage. Additionally, you’ll prevent the Dung Eater from spreading his Seedbed Curses and causing further chaos in the Lands Between.
Is the Dung Eater’s Ending Worth It?
The Dung Eater’s ending, while dark and twisted, can be seen as a way to "punish" the Dung Eater for his heinous actions. However, it’s important to consider whether the reward is worth the moral implications of this ending.
The Least Popular Ending in Elden Ring
The Blessing of Despair is often considered one of the least popular endings in Elden Ring. This is because it curses all living beings in the Lands Between, effectively creating a world where everyone is suffering. This ending can be seen as a moral failure, as it doesn’t provide a solution to the problems of the Lands Between.
The Best Ending in Elden Ring
On the other hand, the Age of Stars ending, which can be achieved through Ranni’s questline, is often considered one of the best endings in Elden Ring. This ending brings about a world where everyone is at peace, and the Lands Between are reborn. This ending is often seen as a moral victory, as it provides a solution to the problems of the Lands Between.
The Moral Implications of Each Ending
The Dung Eater’s ending, while dark and twisted, can be seen as a way to "punish" the Dung Eater for his heinous actions. However, it’s important to consider whether the reward is worth the moral implications of this ending. The Age of Stars ending, on the other hand, brings about a world where everyone is at peace, and the Lands Between are reborn. This ending is often seen as a moral victory, as it provides a solution to the problems of the Lands Between.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the decision to kill or spare the Dung Eater is a crucial one in Elden Ring. While the Dung Eater’s ending may seem appealing to some players, it’s important to consider the moral implications of this ending. The Age of Stars ending, on the other hand, brings about a world where everyone is at peace, and the Lands Between are reborn. This ending is often seen as a moral victory, as it provides a solution to the problems of the Lands Between.
Recommendations
- If you’re interested in exploring the darker side of Elden Ring, consider sparing the Dung Eater and experiencing the Blessing of Despair ending.
- If you’re looking for a more positive and uplifting ending, consider killing the Dung Eater and achieving the Age of Stars ending.
- Regardless of your decision, make sure to consider the moral implications of each ending and choose the one that aligns with your values.
Key Takeaways
- The Dung Eater’s questline is a crucial part of the Elden Ring story.
- Sparing the Dung Eater rewards you with the Mending Rune of the Fell Curse, which is used to unlock the Blessing of Despair ending.
- Killing the Dung Eater rewards you with the Omen armor set and prevents the Dung Eater from spreading his Seedbed Curses.
- The Blessing of Despair ending is often considered one of the least popular endings in Elden Ring.
- The Age of Stars ending is often considered one of the best endings in Elden Ring.
Additional Resources
- "The Best and Worst Endings in Elden Ring" – ScreenRant
- "Elden Ring’s Canon Ending Is Probably Its Default Ending" – ScreenRant
- "The 6 Saddest NPCs In Elden Ring, Ranked" – CBR