Should I kill Dung Eater after giving potion?

Should I Kill Dung Eater After Giving Potion?

In the world of Elden Ring, there are many challenging decisions to make, and one of the most pressing questions is whether to kill Dung Eater after giving him the potion. This decision can have significant consequences on your journey, and in this article, we’ll explore the reasons why you might want to kill Dung Eater, and the benefits and drawbacks of doing so.

The Dung Eater Questline

The Dung Eater questline is one of the more unusual storylines in Elden Ring, and it’s definitely not for the faint of heart. As you progress through the game, you’ll encounter the Dung Eater, a character who is obsessed with his own dung and seems to have a strange connection to the dark magic of the Lands Between. If you give him the potion, he’ll become even more powerful, but this comes at a great cost.

Should I Kill Dung Eater?

So, should you kill Dung Eater after giving him the potion? The answer is yes, but not without some significant consequences. Here are some reasons why:

Benefits of Killing Dung Eater

• Lore Rewards: By killing Dung Eater, you’ll unlock some significant lore rewards, including the ability to access new areas and items.
• Puppet Rewards: Killing Dung Eater will also grant you the ability to use his puppet, which has some powerful abilities and can be a valuable addition to your team.
• Reducing the Power of the Seedbed Curses: The Seedbed Curses are a powerful and terrifying force in the Lands Between, and killing Dung Eater will help to reduce their power.

Drawbacks of Killing Dung Eater

• Loss of Powerful Abilities: By killing Dung Eater, you’ll also lose access to his powerful abilities, which can be a significant loss for your team.
• Negative Impact on Nepheli: Killing Dung Eater will also have a negative impact on Nepheli, who is heavily influenced by the dark magic of the Lands Between. This can make her a more difficult character to manage and may affect your overall progress.

Alternatives to Killing Dung Eater

• Using the Potion for Nepheli: Instead of giving the potion to Dung Eater, you can use it to make Nepheli a puppet, which can be a more beneficial option in the long run.
• Giving the Potion to Gideon: Alternatively, you can give the potion to Gideon, who can use it to further his own goals and ambitions.

Conclusion

In conclusion, killing Dung Eater after giving him the potion is a difficult decision that requires careful consideration. While there are some significant benefits to killing him, there are also some significant drawbacks to consider. Ultimately, the decision is yours, and it’s up to you to weigh the pros and cons and decide what’s best for your character and your journey.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JkpiFpgm3q0