Should I let Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar?

Should I Let Shadowheart Become a Dark Justiciar?

Shadowheart, a complex and intriguing character in Baldur’s Gate 3, poses a crucial question to players: should I let her become a Dark Justiciar of Shar? This article delves into the consequences of such a decision, weighing the pros and cons, and providing guidance on what to expect.

Direct Answer

Yes, you can let Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar, but it’s essential to consider the implications of this choice. Shadowheart will gain powerful gear and a new set of abilities if she becomes a Dark Justiciar, including the legendary weapon Shar’s Spear of Evening. However, this decision will come with significant consequences, affecting not only Shadowheart but also your party and the story.

Consequences of Becoming a Dark Justiciar

If Shadowheart becomes a Dark Justiciar, she will abandon her former life and followers. Her hair will turn silvery white, a visual representation of her changed allegiance. This choice will also affect your relationships with other characters, potentially creating tension or altering alliances.

Pros of Becoming a Dark Justiciar

• Gaining powerful gear and abilities: Shadowheart will receive powerful equipment and abilities, including Shar’s Spear of Evening, which can significantly impact combat.
• Altering the story: Your choice will influence the direction of the story, potentially opening up new possibilities and characters.

Cons of Becoming a Dark Justiciar

• Negative consequences for relationships: Shadowheart’s new allegiance will likely create tension with former allies and potentially alter your relationships with other characters.
• Loss of previous motivations: Shadowheart’s change in allegiance may also lead to a shift in her motivations and values, potentially altering her interactions and behavior.

Can You Turn Shadowheart from Shar?

Yes, you can turn Shadowheart from Shar’s influence. Later in the game, as she contemplates her future, you can discuss how she’d build her future with you. If you choose to pursue a relationship with her, she’ll abandon Shar’s influence and her hair will return to its original color.

Shadowheart’s Approval List

Romancing Shadowheart requires certain choices and actions. Her approval list includes:

• Kindness towards children
• Kindness towards animals
• Avoiding unnecessary violence where possible with persuasion or manipulation
• Showing distrust towards the Gith
• Fighting against oppression
• Allowing her to be faithful to Shar where possible

Persuading Shadowheart to Abandon Shar

To persuade Shadowheart to abandon Shar, you’ll need to make the right choices and have a good relationship with her. The skill check to persuade her can have a DC anywhere from 14 to 30, depending on your choices and relationship with her.

Table: Consequences of Becoming a Dark Justiciar

Conclusion

Letting Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar is a significant choice with far-reaching consequences. Weighing the pros and cons, it’s essential to consider how this decision will impact your party, relationships, and the story. While Shadowheart will gain powerful gear and abilities, this choice will also alter the narrative and potentially create tension with other characters. Make an informed decision, taking into account the potential outcomes and the importance of relationships within the game.