Should I Show Gideon the Potion?
As you navigate the world of Elden Ring, you come across a mysterious potion that holds significant importance. But the question remains – what should you do with it? Should you give it to Gideon Ofnir, the grumpy man sitting at a desk outside the Table of Grace room, or keep it for yourself? In this article, we’ll dive into the pros and cons of each option to help you make an informed decision.
Direct Answer
The best option is to give the potion to Gideon Ofnir. This choice allows you to continue both Nepheli Loux and Kenneth Haight’s questlines while also unlocking the Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone.
Why Give the Potion to Gideon?
Pros:
- Continues Nepheli and Kenneth Haight’s questlines
- Unlocks the Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone
- Best option for progressing the game’s story
Cons:
- Gives Gideon the upper hand, potentially making future battles more challenging
- You’ll miss out on some exclusive rewards if you give it to him
What Happens if You Keep the Potion?
Pros:
- Keeps the potion for yourself, potentially using it to boost your character’s stats
- Avoids giving Gideon the upper hand
Cons:
- Misses out on continuing Nepheli and Kenneth Haight’s questlines
- May struggle to progress the game’s story without the potion’s benefits
Alternatives to Giving the Potion to Gideon
- Give the potion to Seluvis, but be warned that this will lock you out of Nepheli’s questline
- Use the potion on your character, but be prepared for the potential drawbacks
- Experiment with other options, such as selling or storing the potion, to see what works best for your playstyle
Conclusion
Giving the potion to Gideon Ofnir is the best option for progressing the game’s story and continuing both Nepheli Loux and Kenneth Haight’s questlines. While it may come with some risks, the benefits outweigh the drawbacks. If you choose to keep the potion or give it to someone else, be prepared for the potential consequences.