Should you free the ghost in the tree?

Should You Free the Ghost in the Tree?

In the world of The Witcher 3, the question of whether to free the ghost in the tree is a decision that weighs heavily on the shoulders of the protagonist, Geralt of Rivia. The fate of two innocent characters hangs in the balance, and it is up to the player to make the choice.

What Happens if You Free the Ghost in the Tree?

When you choose to free the ghost in the tree, the tree will be released from its spectral imprisonment, and the curse that afflicted it will be lifted. This will restore the tree’s natural beauty, and the village of Downwarren, which was suffering under the curse, will flourish once again. The ghost, known as the "tree spirit", will also be released from its prison, but its fate is unknown.

However, the cost of freeing the tree is severe. By releasing the curse, you will be cursing Anna, the Baron’s wife, who is already under a wicked spell. She will be taken away from her husband, and her future is uncertain.

The Consequences of Releasing the Curse

Releasing the curse has multiple consequences for Geralt, Ciri, and Anna:

• Anna will be taken away: The Baron’s wife, Anna, will be cursed and removed from the game.
• Loss of Geralt’s chance for redemption: Geralt, being a professional witcher, has an opportunity to help the Baron and his family.
• New threat emerges: By releasing the curse, a new, potentially powerful force will be unleashed on the Continent.
• Impact on future events: The fate of the villagers, including Ciri, will also be altered by releasing the curse.

Do the Crones Play a Role?

Yes, the Crones are directly involved in this quest. By fighting and defeating them, Ciri and Geralt can alter the course of the game, making it possible to free the tree while sparing Anna. However, if the Crones are not defeated, it is still possible to free the tree, but the consequences will be severe.

An Alternative Option: Failing the Rescue

Instead of freeing the curse, Geralt can fail the rescue, and save Anna by leaving the Baron’s wife in prison. Anna will die if the rescue is not successful.

Comparison of Choices

To make an informed decision, here are some points to consider for both choices:

Freeing the Curse:

• The tree’s curse is lifted, and the village benefits.
• Geralt’s reputation grows as a powerful witcher.
• Consequences for Geralt and Anna’s fate are severe and long-term.

Failing the Rescue:

• Anna lives, but in prison.
• Geralt’s reputation diminishes due to the failure.
• Anna will still suffer the curse’s influence, potentially causing more harm than good.

The Final Choice: Yours

In conclusion, deciding whether to free the ghost in the tree in The Witcher 3 is a heavy decision. Weighing the costs and consequences, players must consider the impact of both choices on Geralt, Ciri, Anna, and the game’s events.

As a final thought, what do you value more – saving lives or preserving the natural order? Ultimately, the choice lies in the hands of the player.