Should You Give the Seluvis Potion to Gideon or Nepheli?
As you navigate the world of Elden Ring, you’ll encounter various choices that can significantly impact the story and its characters. One such decision is whether to give the Seluvis potion to Gideon or Nepheli. Both options have their pros and cons, and in this article, we’ll help you make an informed choice.
Direct Answer
Give the potion to Gideon. But before we dive into the reasoning, let’s first highlight the consequences of each option.
What Happens if You Give the Potion to Gideon?
If you choose to give the potion to Gidon, you’ll be able to continue talking with Seluvis, buy things from him, and complete other quests related to Nepheli, Sellen, and Dung Eater. This option allows for a more streamlined experience and opens up additional story paths.
What Happens if You Give the Potion to Nepheli?
If you decide to give the potion to Nepheli, she’ll turn into a doll and leave Roundtable Hold. This option has significant story implications, as it can lock you out of other quests and character interactions. Additionally, you’ll only be able to buy Spirit Ashes from Seluvis, which may not be as valuable as the other rewards.
Considering the Consequences
It’s essential to weigh the pros and cons of each option carefully. If you’re interested in completing as many quests as possible, giving the potion to Gideon is the better choice. This will allow you to progress through the story and interact with other characters.
On the other hand, if you’re only interested in progressing Nepheli’s storyline, giving the potion to her may be the way to go. However, be aware that this will limit your options and may impact future story choices.
Tips and Strategies
- Check the quest requirements: Make sure you understand the prerequisites for each quest and ensure that giving the potion to one character won’t close off other story paths.
- Plan your gameplay: Think about your short-term and long-term goals in the game. Do you want to focus on completing specific quests or do you want to explore different storylines?
- Experiment and adjust: If you choose to give the potion to one character, don’t be afraid to experiment and adjust your decision later on. The Elden Ring has a relatively open-world design, and you can always go back and make changes to previous choices.
Comparison of Options
| Option | Consequences |
|---|---|
| Gideon | Ability to continue talking with Seluvis, buy items, and complete other quests |
| Nepheli | Nepheli becomes a doll and leaves Roundtable Hold; limited quest options |
In conclusion, giving the Seluvis potion to Gideon is generally the better choice. However, if you’re determined to progress Nepheli’s storyline, be prepared for the potential consequences of limiting your quest options.
Remember to always weigh your choices carefully and consider your short-term and long-term goals in the game. With this article, we hope you’ve made a more informed decision about the fate of the Seluvis potion.