Was Abigail the Rat RDR2?
The question of who was the traitor in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) has been a topic of debate among fans and players. While some believe it was Micah Bell, others argue that it was Abigail Roberts, the wife of John Marston and the mother of Jack Marston. In this article, we will explore the evidence and theories surrounding Abigail’s potential role as the rat in RDR2.
The Case Against Abigail
At first glance, it may seem unlikely that Abigail was the rat. She was a loyal member of the Van der Linde gang and was deeply involved in the gang’s activities. However, there are several points that suggest she may have been involved in the betrayal.
- Abigail’s desire to leave the gang: Throughout the game, Abigail expresses her desire to leave the gang and start a new life with John and Jack. This desire could have led her to seek a way out, potentially by betraying the gang.
- Abigail’s conversations with John: In several conversations with John, Abigail mentions her concerns about the gang’s future and her desire to leave. These conversations could be seen as a way for her to gauge John’s loyalty and potentially manipulate him into doing her bidding.
- Abigail’s actions during the Saint Denis bank job: During the Saint Denis bank job, Abigail is seen acting suspiciously, potentially indicating that she was involved in the betrayal.
The Case For Abigail
While there are several points that suggest Abigail may have been involved in the betrayal, there are also several points that argue against it.
- Abigail’s loyalty to the gang: Throughout the game, Abigail is shown to be a loyal member of the Van der Linde gang. She is deeply involved in the gang’s activities and is willing to risk her life to protect her fellow gang members.
- Abigail’s conversations with Micah: In several conversations with Micah, Abigail expresses her disdain for his actions and her desire to leave the gang. This could suggest that she was not involved in the betrayal and was actually trying to distance herself from Micah’s influence.
- Abigail’s actions during the final mission: During the final mission, Abigail is seen fighting alongside John and the gang to take down Micah. This could suggest that she was not involved in the betrayal and was actually loyal to the gang.
Theories and Speculation
While there is no concrete evidence that proves Abigail was the rat, there are several theories and speculations that have been put forth by fans and players.
- The "Karen" theory: Some fans believe that Karen, a character who is mentioned in the game, was actually the rat. This theory suggests that Karen was a mole within the gang who was feeding information to the Pinkertons.
- The "Milton" theory: Another theory suggests that Milton, a character who is mentioned in the game, was actually the rat. This theory suggests that Milton was a high-ranking member of the Pinkertons who was working to take down the Van der Linde gang.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while there are several points that suggest Abigail may have been involved in the betrayal, there are also several points that argue against it. Ultimately, the question of who was the rat in RDR2 remains a topic of debate and speculation among fans and players.