Was the Rumbling a success?

Was the Rumbling a Success?

The Rumbling, a catastrophic event in the world of Attack on Titan, has left a lasting impact on the story and its characters. Eren Yeager’s decision to initiate the Rumbling, with the goal of protecting his people and annihilating their enemies, has sparked a multitude of opinions on whether his actions were successful or not. In this article, we will delve into the consequences of the Rumbling and examine the arguments for and against its success.

Direct Answer: No, the Rumbling was not a success

The Rumbling resulted in the destruction of 80% of the world’s population, leaving behind a devastated landscape and a small fraction of survivors. The event was a devastating blow to humanity, and the consequences of Eren’s actions will be felt for generations to come. The loss of life and destruction caused by the Rumbling cannot be justified, and it can be argued that it was a failure on a monumental scale.

Eren’s Motivations

Eren’s motivations for initiating the Rumbling were rooted in his desire to protect his people, the Eldians, from persecution and annihilation. He believed that the only way to ensure their survival was to eliminate their enemies, the Marleyans, and anyone else who stood in their way. Eren’s actions were driven by a desire to preserve his people’s existence, but the consequences of his actions were far-reaching and devastating.

The Consequences of the Rumbling

The Rumbling had far-reaching consequences, including:

• Mass destruction and loss of life: The Rumbling resulted in the deaths of millions of people, leaving behind a devastated landscape and a small fraction of survivors.
• Loss of infrastructure and resources: The destruction caused by the Rumbling has left the world without access to critical infrastructure and resources, making it difficult for survivors to rebuild and recover.
• Environmental damage: The Rumbling has had a devastating impact on the environment, with the destruction of entire ecosystems and the release of toxic chemicals into the air and water.
• Social and psychological trauma: The Rumbling has left behind a trail of social and psychological trauma, with survivors struggling to cope with the loss of loved ones and the devastation caused by the event.

Arguments for the Rumbling’s Success

Despite the devastating consequences of the Rumbling, there are some arguments that can be made for its success:

• Protection of the Eldians: The Rumbling did achieve its primary goal of protecting the Eldians from persecution and annihilation, at least in the short term.
• Destruction of the Marleyans: The Rumbling did result in the destruction of the Marleyans, who were the primary targets of Eren’s anger and desire for revenge.
• New opportunities for humanity: The Rumbling has created new opportunities for humanity to rebuild and start anew, with the chance to create a better future for themselves and their children.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Rumbling was not a success. The devastating consequences of the event, including the loss of life, destruction of infrastructure, and environmental damage, far outweigh any benefits that may have been achieved. Eren’s actions were driven by a desire to protect his people, but the consequences of his actions were far-reaching and devastating.

Recommendations for Rebuilding and Recovery

In the aftermath of the Rumbling, there are several steps that can be taken to rebuild and recover:

• Establish a new government: A new government should be established to provide leadership and direction in the rebuilding process.
• Provide aid and support to survivors: Aid and support should be provided to survivors, including food, shelter, and medical care.
• Rebuild critical infrastructure: Critical infrastructure, such as hospitals, schools, and transportation systems, should be rebuilt as quickly as possible.
• Promote social and psychological healing: Efforts should be made to promote social and psychological healing, including counseling and support services for survivors.

By following these steps, it may be possible to rebuild and recover from the devastating consequences of the Rumbling, and to create a better future for all humanity.