What Happens if a Commander is Exiled from the Graveyard?
In the world of Commander, a commander’s departure from the game can happen in various ways, such as being exiled, destroyed, or sacrificed. In this article, we will explore what happens to a commander when it is exiled from the graveyard.
Direct Answer
According to the Commander rules, if a commander would be put into a graveyard or exile from anywhere, the owner may choose to move it to the command zone instead. This means that if a commander is exiled from the graveyard, the owner can choose to move it back to the command zone.
Return to the Command Zone
When a commander is exiled from the graveyard, the owner has the opportunity to return it to the command zone. This option is only available if the commander was put into a graveyard or exile from anywhere. If the commander is exiled from the battlefield, it will remain exiled and cannot be moved back to the command zone.
Consequences of Exiling a Commander from the Graveyard
If a commander is exiled from the graveyard, its effects will remain on the battlefield. Any counters that were on the commander before it was exiled will remain on the battlefield as well. Additionally, the commander’s triggered abilities and effects will not trigger immediately, but will trigger instead when the commander is placed back into the command zone.
When Exiling from the Graveyard is Helpful
Exiling a commander from the graveyard can sometimes be a helpful strategy, especially if the commander was about to be destroyed by an opponent’s spell. By exiling the commander, the owner can get rid of it and allow it to return to the command zone at a later time.
When Not to Exile from the Graveyard
On the other hand, exiling a commander from the graveyard can also have negative consequences. For example, if the commander has a large number of counters on it, exiling it would mean losing those counters, which could be detrimental to the game.
Return to the Command Zone Requirements
To return a commander to the command zone after it has been exiled from the graveyard, it must meet the following conditions:
- The commander has been exiled from anywhere, not just the battlefield.
- The commander has not been destroyed or destroyed by an opponent’s effect.
- The commander does not have any counters attached to it that would not be allowed on the commander.
Consequences for the Opponent
Exiling a commander from the graveyard can have consequences for the opponent as well. For example, if a commander is exiled from the graveyard, it will lose any counters that were attached to it. Additionally, the commander’s triggered abilities and effects will not trigger immediately, which could create an opportunity for the commander’s owner to take the initiative.
Conclusion
Exiling a commander from the graveyard can be a tactical decision that requires careful consideration. By understanding the effects of exiling a commander and the conditions required for it to return to the command zone, players can make informed decisions about their commander’s fate. With this knowledge, players can develop strategies that take into account the possibilities and limitations of exiling a commander from the graveyard.
Table: Consequences of Exiling a Commander from the Graveyard
| Consequences for Commander | Consequences for Opponent | |
|---|---|---|
| Counters | Loses counters | Lose counters |
| Trigger Abilities | Trigger abilities may not trigger immediately | N/A |
| Destiny | May come back to the command zone with counters | N/A |
| Game State | Changes the game state (e.g., removes ability to attack) | Has an opportunity to take control of the game |
The following are the main questions and answers related to the Commander rules:
Q: What happens if a Commander is exiled from the graveyard?
A: The owner can choose to move it to the Command Zone instead.
Q: Can a Commander still trigger its abilities if exiled from the graveyard?
A: No, its triggered abilities will not trigger immediately. They will trigger when the Commander returns to the Command Zone.
Q: Can an exiled Commander still contribute to the game state from the graveyard?
A: No, it must be returned to the command zone to contribute to the game state.
Q: Can an exiled Commander still attack or cast spells from the graveyard?
A: No, it must be returned to the command zone to allow it to attack or cast spells.
Q: Can an exiled Commander still be affected by permanents or spells on the battlefield?
A: Yes, it can be affected by permanents and spells on the battlefield regardless of its exile status.
Q: Can I exile a Commander from exile?
A: Yes, you can exile an exiled Commander to place it in a new Zone.
Q: Will an exiled Commander become a new card?
A: No, once a Commander is exiled, it will remain part of the game and you can still manipulate it’s exile status.