What happens if I give RYA the Tonic of Forgetfulness?

What Happens if I Give RYA the Tonic of Forgetfulness?

The Tonic of Forgetfulness is a crucial item in Elden Ring, and using it wisely can significantly impact the story. One of the most important decisions players must make is what to do with this item. In this article, we will delve into the consequences of giving RYA the Tonic of Forgetfulness and explore the outcomes of this choice.

Refusing to Give RYA the Tonic

If you refuse to give RYA the Tonic of Forgetfulness, Lady Tanith will be pleased with your decision. This choice ultimately leads to the good ending. RYA will leave behind both the talisman and a note, acknowledging your actions. It’s essential to understand that ignoring RYA’s request is crucial in this situation, as it allows her to fulfill her role in the story and contributes to the game’s ultimate conclusion.

Consequences of Giving RYA the Tonic

Giving RYA the Tonic of Forgetfulness leads to a darker ending. Tanith will not be pleased with your decision, and RYA will soon disappear, leaving behind only the talisman. This choice will ultimately lead to Rya’s demise.

Brother Corhyn: The Forgotten NPC

Giving the Tonic to Corhyn results in his immediate demise, and Goldmask will no longer be available. Corhyn’s storyline will not continue, and his importance in the narrative will be diminished.

Golden Mask: A Disappearance

When Goldmask is given the Tonic, he will vanish permanently, leaving no trail or breadcrumbs for players to follow. His fate remains a mystery, adding to the intrigue and mystique of Elden Ring’s narrative.

Rykard: A Foreshadowing

Giving the Tonic to Corhyn may foreshadow Rya’s ultimate demise. Rykard, Lord of Blasphemy, is the primary suspect in this narrative twist. His relentless pursuit of power may ultimately seal Rya’s fate, leading to a catastrophic outcome.

In-Game Locations

To confirm the Tonic’s impact, check the following in-game locations:

Conclusions and Implications

The choice to give or not give the Tonic of Forgetfulness to RYA is crucial in shaping the story. Ignoring RYA’s request leads to the good ending, while giving in results in a darker outcome. Corhyn’s fate is also influenced by this choice, as giving the Tonic to him leads to his immediate demise. The narrative’s trajectory changes significantly based on these decisions, and understanding the implications of these choices is vital to grasping Elden Ring’s intricate storyline.

Ultimately, the choice to give or refuse the Tonic of Forgetfulness to RYA is a test of players’ decision-making skills. By weighing the consequences and outcomes, players can shape the narrative, influence character fates, and unlock new insights into the game’s mysterious world.