What Happens If You Save the Man from Blackwater?
In Red Dead Redemption 2, the infamous Blackwater mission is a pivotal moment in the game’s storyline. The player is tasked with robbing a bank, but things take a deadly turn when the plan goes awry. In the midst of the chaos, a lone man falls to his death, leaving you with a choice: take his life or spare his. This article will explore what happens if you save the man from Blackwater.
The Consequences of Your Choice
Saving the man from Blackwater has several consequences that ripple throughout the game. While it may seem like a small act, it sets in motion a chain of events that can significantly impact the game’s storyline. Here are some of the key consequences:
• Gift and Honor: Saving the man earns you a gift from him, a small gesture of gratitude. Additionally, your honor is boosted, reflecting the importance of the decision.
The Pros and Cons
Saving the man from Blackwater is not without its drawbacks. Here are some of the pros and cons to consider:
Pros:
• Gained Honor: As mentioned earlier, saving the man from Blackwater boosts your honor, a crucial aspect of the game.
• Gift: You receive a small gift from the rescued man, a tangible token of appreciation.
• Positive Character Development: Sparring the man’s life highlights your compassion and humanity, making you a more empathetic character.
Cons:
• Perceived Cowardice: Some gang members, such as Micah, might view your decision as weak or cowardly, affecting your relationships with them.
Impact on the Gang
Your decision to spare the man from Blackwater has far-reaching implications on the gang’s dynamics and relationships:
• John’s Perspective: John’s opinion of you is unaffected by this decision, remaining neutral.
• Arthur’s Reaction: Arthur respects your choice, considering you a true friend and potential leader.
• Dutch’s Reaction: Dutch, however, views your decision as a sign of weakness and a lack of commitment to the gang.
Comparison to Other Endings
To put your decision into perspective, let’s compare it to the outcomes of other endings:
Killing the Man: If you choose to take the man’s life, you earn a higher yield from the heist and gain Micah’s approval. However, your honor is lower, and Arthur’s perception of you as a potential leader is tainted.
Not Intervening: If you choose not to intervene, the man dies, and you reap the same rewards as when you spare his life, but your honor is significantly lower.
The Power of Choice
In Red Dead Redemption 2, the choices you make as Arthur Morgan have lasting effects on the game’s world and its characters. Your decision to save the man from Blackwater is no exception. By considering the pros and cons, you can weigh the potential implications of your choice and craft a unique narrative for Arthur Morgan.
Conclusion
Saving the man from Blackwater is a significant moment in Red Dead Redemption 2. By making the right choice, you boost your honor, receive a gift, and develop positive relationships with the gang members. While there are downsides to consider, this decision sets a tone for Arthur’s character development, showcasing compassion and humanity in the face of adversity.
Takeaways:
• Save the man to boost your honor and earn a gift.
• Expect a positive reaction from Arthur and potentially John.
• Dutch’s reaction is ambiguous, with some possible anger or disapproval.
• Compare this decision to the outcomes of other endings in the game.
Remember, in Red Dead Redemption 2, the choices you make matter. Make an informed decision, and ride off into the sunset, shaping Arthur Morgan’s narrative in the process.