Which Person Should I Kill in the Dark Brotherhood?
The Dark Brotherhood is a mysterious and intriguing aspect of the Skyrim world, offering a unique storyline and moral dilemmas. As a member of the Brotherhood, you are tasked with eliminating specific targets, but the question remains: who should you kill?
Killing Astrid or the Khajiit
In the initial stages of the Dark Brotherhood quest, you are presented with the option to kill Astrid or the Khajiit, Vasha. Killing Astrid will result in a failed quest and the disappearance of the Dark Brotherhood from the game. On the other hand, killing Vasha is recommended by Astrid herself, as he is described as a murderer, rapist, and thief. However, it’s essential to note that the victim’s background and motivations are not explicitly stated, leaving you to make an informed decision.
The Traitor Within
As you progress through the Dark Brotherhood storyline, you will uncover the truth about the traitor who betrayed the Brotherhood. Mathieu Bellamont, a former Speaker, was the one responsible for the Purification of the Cheydinhal Sanctuary. This event led to the death of many innocent people and the destruction of the Brotherhood.
Wiping Out the Dark Brotherhood
If you have killed Astrid in the shack, you will start a short quest to eliminate the Dark Brotherhood members. This can be achieved by killing the remaining members and completing the related quests. However, it’s crucial to note that this will not result in a significant impact on the game’s storyline.
Joining the Dark Brotherhood
Joining the Dark Brotherhood will not have any significant consequences on your game. You will still be able to access the Sanctuary and interact with the members, but your actions will not be recognized by the guards.
Adopting Babette
If you choose to adopt Babette, she will still offer you Alchemy training, but you will not be able to access her merchant inventory.
Consequences of Your Choices
The choices you make in the Dark Brotherhood quest will have significant consequences. Killing Astrid will result in a failed quest and the disappearance of the Brotherhood, while killing Vasha will align with Astrid’s recommendations. Wiping out the Dark Brotherhood will eliminate the members, but not have a significant impact on the game’s storyline.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Dark Brotherhood offers a complex and intriguing storyline, filled with moral dilemmas and challenging choices. Killing Astrid or Vasha will have different consequences, while wiping out the Dark Brotherhood will eliminate the members, but not have a significant impact on the game’s storyline. Ultimately, the choice is yours to make, and the consequences will depend on the decisions you take.
Key Points
- Killing Astrid will result in a failed quest and the disappearance of the Dark Brotherhood.
- Killing Vasha is recommended by Astrid, but the victim’s background and motivations are not explicitly stated.
- Wiping out the Dark Brotherhood will eliminate the members, but not have a significant impact on the game’s storyline.
- Joining the Dark Brotherhood will not have any significant consequences on your game.
- Adopting Babette will still offer you Alchemy training, but you will not be able to access her merchant inventory.
Table: Dark Brotherhood Consequences
| Action | Consequences |
|---|---|
| Killing Astrid | Failed quest, disappearance of the Dark Brotherhood |
| Killing Vasha | Alignment with Astrid’s recommendations, no explicit consequences |
| Wiping out the Dark Brotherhood | Elimination of members, no significant impact on the game’s storyline |
| Joining the Dark Brotherhood | No significant consequences on your game |
| Adopting Babette | Alchemy training, no access to merchant inventory |
Conclusion
The Dark Brotherhood offers a unique and complex storyline, filled with moral dilemmas and challenging choices. By understanding the consequences of your actions, you can make informed decisions and shape the story of Skyrim.