Who should I give the black star to in Skyrim?

Who Should I Give the Black Star to in Skyrim?

The Black Star is one of the most coveted and powerful artifacts in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. Obtained by completing the Daedric Quest "The Black Star", this star is said to grant the wielder immense power and control over the forces of darkness. But, the question remains: who should you give the Black Star to?

Azura’s Star vs. Nelacar’s Trap

Before we dive into the decision, let’s briefly discuss the two options: Azura’s Star and Nelacar’s Trap. Azura’s Star is a soul gem that can trap any soul except for black souls, while Nelacar’s Trap can trap all souls, including black ones. This difference is crucial in determining who to give the Black Star to.

Who is Azura?

Azura is a Daedric Princess, also known as the Queen of Dawn and Dusk. She is associated with the magic of dawn and dusk, and is said to have created the world of Tamriel. In Skyrim, Azura is a revered figure, and her followers believe that she has the power to bring balance and harmony to the world.

Who is Nelacar?

Nelacar is a wizard who resides in the Frozen Hearth Inn in Winterhold. He is an expert in the dark arts and is said to have created the Trap that can capture all souls, including black ones.

The Decision: Azura or Nelacar?

Now that we’ve discussed the two options, let’s weigh the pros and cons of giving the Black Star to Azura or Nelacar.

Pros of Giving to Azura:

• Balanced Power: Azura’s Star is a balanced soul gem that can trap most souls, except for black ones. This means that the wielder will have a greater range of options for trapping souls, and will not be limited to only capturing black souls.
• Respect for Azura: Giving the Black Star to Azura shows respect for her power and wisdom. As a revered figure in Skyrim, Azura is a symbol of balance and harmony, and giving her the Black Star would be a gesture of good faith.

Cons of Giving to Azura:

• Limited Power: As mentioned earlier, Azura’s Star has limited power, as it cannot trap black souls. This means that the wielder may miss out on the opportunity to capture powerful souls.
• No Additional Rewards: Giving the Black Star to Azura does not provide any additional rewards or bonuses.

Pros of Giving to Nelacar:

• Unlimited Power: Nelacar’s Trap is a powerful tool that can capture all souls, including black ones. This means that the wielder will have unlimited power and control over the forces of darkness.
• Additional Rewards: Giving the Black Star to Nelacar provides additional rewards, including the ability to create powerful soul gems and to cast powerful spells.

Cons of Giving to Nelacar:

• Dark Magic: Nelacar’s Trap is a dark and powerful tool that is associated with the dark arts. Using it may have negative consequences, such as attracting unwanted attention from the Daedra.
• Unbalanced Power: Giving the Black Star to Nelacar may lead to unbalanced power, as the wielder may have too much control over the forces of darkness.

The Verdict: Who Should You Give the Black Star to?

Ultimately, the decision of who to give the Black Star to depends on your playstyle and goals. If you want a balanced power and respect for Azura, then giving the Black Star to her may be the best option. However, if you want unlimited power and additional rewards, then giving the Black Star to Nelacar may be the better choice.

Conclusion:

The Black Star is a powerful artifact in Skyrim, and choosing who to give it to can be a difficult decision. By weighing the pros and cons of giving the Black Star to Azura or Nelacar, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your playstyle and goals. Whether you choose to give the Black Star to Azura or Nelacar, remember that the power of the Black Star should be used responsibly and with caution.

Table: Comparison of Azura’s Star and Nelacar’s Trap

Bullets List: Important Points to Consider

• The Black Star is a powerful artifact that can grant the wielder immense power and control over the forces of darkness.
• Azura’s Star is a balanced soul gem that can trap most souls, except for black ones.
• Nelacar’s Trap is a powerful tool that can capture all souls, including black ones.
• Giving the Black Star to Azura shows respect for her power and wisdom.
• Giving the Black Star to Nelacar provides additional rewards, but may lead to unbalanced power and negative consequences.
• The decision of who to give the Black Star to depends on your playstyle and goals.