Who would win between Scarlet Witch and Vecna?
Direct Answer:
Scarlet Witch would likely lose a battle against Vecna due to his immense power, sheer strength, and lack of vulnerability to her usual abilities. Vecna is one of the most iconic villains in Dungeons & Dragons and has been the object of many a brave soul’s quest. Scarlet Witch, on the other hand, is a formidable avenger with impressive powers but would struggle to counter the mad titan’s formidable attacks.
The Boggart of Vecna vs Scarlet Witch
When assessing their powers, one factor to consider is Vecna’s ability to teleport short distances using the spell "Teleport Without Error" [D&D‘s 5th Ed., p. 272] and his "Planar Ally" feature (Monster Manual, p. 314). Vecna, as a being native to the Shadowfell (an otherworldly plane), has access to forces and energies that defy traditional concepts of space and matter.
The Magical Advantage of Vecna
This "Planar Ally" ability allows Vecna to bring forth powerful creatures like demon lords, lesser deities, or other dark, otherworldly energies, which would severely neutralize Scarlet Witch’s teleportation abilities. His inherent magic, including Major Illusions and Wall of Force to control the battlefield and dispel Scarlet Witch’s enchantments, would leave Wanda struggling to gain control. Additionally, Cackle (from Volo’s Guide page 130), while non-magical and relatively weak, still reflects his mastery over death.
The Unbeatable Combination of Vecna and Death
As Vecna combines his powers with Death (which I argue is a unique domain due to his extensive, literal connection to it). When considering the interactions, both Vecna’s necrotic magic and magical properties would become enhanced further due to his symbiosis with Death. He gained immunity to necrotic damage, which makes Scarlete Witch’s teleporting attack less effective against a direct hit. As, death itself, Scarlet witch may struggle to make real a direct hit without it disintegrating as there might be a significant molecular damage, also. We can say his is much more resistant, perhaps less vulnerable, with or even more resilient as she’d be, considering Wanda’s powers being rooted on chaos magic which aren’t as strong compared
The Conclusion: Wanda’s Powers Invalued
While Wanda, as Scarlet Witch, should never be underestimated due to her impressive powers and limitless creativity, she stretched beyond control, and Vecna, with his arsenal (with Planar ally) and mastery of, with Death himself to back him, with and necromantic powers; thusly, the latter shall hold the upper hand by controlling the battlefield using abilities of Teleport With Error, the aforementioned teleportation spell with little no chance of him accidentally jumping to the same distance the other way wall of force to shield himself** in anticipation.
In-depth Insights