Why can’t John swim?

Why Can’t John Swim?

A Look into the Inability of Red Dead Redemption 2’s Protagonist

Red Dead Redemption 2’s protagonist, Arthur Morgan, is not the only one who faces difficulties in the game. John Marston, his mentor and fellow outlaw, is another character who faces unique challenges, including his inability to swim. In this article, we will explore why John can’t swim and what it means for his character in the game.

Canonical Reason:

According to the game’s developers, John’s inability to swim is canonical, meaning it is rooted in the game’s narrative. In the game’s storyline, John never learned how to swim, and his character design reflects this. This aspect of John’s character serves as a reminder of his humble beginnings and the circumstances that led him to become an outlaw.

Comparing with Arthur Morgan:

For comparison, Arthur Morgan, John’s protege and successor, can swim with relative ease. This skill is demonstrated during the game’s mission to cross the river. While Arthur takes some time to get across, John, on the other hand, struggles and quickly exhausts his stamina. This comparison highlights John’s limited physical abilities and further reinforces his inability to swim.

Mechanical Implementation:

The mechanical implementation of John’s swimming ability (or lack thereof) is designed to enhance the gameplay experience. When John enters water, his stamina quickly depletes, making it impossible for him to survive for more than a few seconds. This constraint serves as a reminder of John’s physical limitations and the dangers that come with water. For players, it presents an additional layer of realism and immersion.

Table: Swimming Mechanics Comparison

Impact on Storyline and Gameplay:

John’s inability to swim has a significant impact on the storyline and gameplay. During key missions, such as the river crossing, John’s limitations can make it difficult for players to progress. This requires strategic thinking and planning to ensure John’s survival, adding an extra layer of complexity to the game. The consequences of John’s actions are more pronounced due to his limited abilities, making the player’s choices and decisions more impactful.

Significance in the Storyline:

John’s inability to swim is a poignant reflection of his character’s history and background. His inability to save his wife and son in Red Dead Redemption 1 (which occurred due to his lack of swimming skills) is a significant aspect of his storyline. The guilt and trauma he carries as a result of that event have lasting effects on his character development and relationship with his loved ones. His inability to swim in Red Dead Redemption 2 serves as a reminder of those past traumas and his struggles with redemption.

Conclusion:

John Marston’s inability to swim is an integral aspect of his character in Red Dead Redemption 2. From a mechanical standpoint, it enhances the gameplay experience by introducing realistic limitations. On a narrative level, it provides a unique insight into John’s backstory and emotional struggles. Through his limitations, we are reminded of his human vulnerability and the weight of his past experiences. As a result, John’s character becomes even more relatable and believable, adding depth to the game’s already rich storyline.

H2 References:

[1] "Why can’t John swim?" article on Red Dead Redemption 2 FAQs.
[2] Game’s developers, Rockstar Games, statement on John’s swimming abilities.
[3] Gameplay footage showcasing John’s swimming struggles.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Amy498oeOuo