Do Enchantments Fall Off If You Give a Creature Hexproof?
Hexproof is a fascinating mechanic in Magic: The Gathering that allows creatures to avoid being targeted by spells and abilities controlled by opponents. But what happens to enchantments on these creatures? Do they fall off, or do they remain attached? In this article, we’ll dive into the intricacies of Hexproof and enchantments to provide a comprehensive answer.
What is Hexproof?
Before we dive into the specifics, let’s briefly define what Hexproof is. Hexproof is a mechanic that prevents a creature from being targeted by spells and abilities controlled by opponents. This means that an opponent cannot use a spell or ability to target a creature with Hexproof, even if the creature has enchantments or other permanents attached to it.
Do Enchantments Fall Off?
So, do enchantments fall off if you give a creature Hexproof? The answer is no. Enchantments remain attached to the creature even after it gains Hexproof. This is because Hexproof only prevents opponents from targeting the creature, but it doesn’t affect the creature’s existing enchantments.
Why Don’t Enchantments Fall Off?
There are a few reasons why enchantments don’t fall off when a creature gains Hexproof:
- Enchantments are not spells or abilities: Enchantments are permanents that remain attached to a creature or other object. They are not spells or abilities that can be targeted by opponents.
- Hexproof only affects targeting: Hexproof only prevents opponents from targeting the creature with spells and abilities. It doesn’t affect the creature’s existing enchantments or other permanents.
- Enchantments are not destroyed: Enchantments are not destroyed or removed when a creature gains Hexproof. They remain attached to the creature and continue to function as normal.
Example Scenarios
Let’s look at a few example scenarios to illustrate how enchantments behave when a creature gains Hexproof:
| Scenario | Enchantment Remains? |
|---|---|
| A creature with Hexproof has an enchantment attached. An opponent tries to remove the enchantment with a spell or ability. | Yes, the enchantment remains attached to the creature. |
| A creature with Hexproof has an enchantment attached. The enchantment is auras and is destroyed. | No, the enchantment is destroyed, regardless of the creature’s Hexproof. |
| A creature with Hexproof has an enchantment attached. The enchantment is a non-auras enchantment and is removed. | No, the enchantment is removed, regardless of the creature’s Hexproof. |
Conclusion
In conclusion, enchantments do not fall off when a creature gains Hexproof. Enchantments remain attached to the creature and continue to function as normal, even after the creature gains Hexproof. This is because Hexproof only prevents opponents from targeting the creature, but it doesn’t affect the creature’s existing enchantments. By understanding how enchantments and Hexproof interact, you can make informed decisions about your deckbuilding and gameplay strategies.